Show newer

@Pat @se7en Limiting the states AND the federal gov't, which like i said is in a lot of the Constitution. The limitation on the federal govt to not be able to suspend habeus corpus is a restriction on the federal govt as well as the states.

@Pat

It is not restricted to a single article. I can think of examples across several articles, in fact there are examples all over the constitition.

Article IV aside another is Article 10, which restricts the ability of the federal government to suspend habius corpus. In fact there is probably an example of a limitation of the governments rights in every, or at least most, articles, at least in some form.

@se7en

@Pat

While that does get the general gist of it I want to point out, the constitution, even without considering the amendments including the bill of rights, lists both the powers of the central government as well as things it can not do in quite a few places. The idea that it exclusdes limitations in its power (and that is solely done int he bill of rights) isnt correct.

But that is a minor enough detail.

@se7en

@se7en

Sadly the constitution says very little on the topic. It doesnt even provide provisions for bodily autonomy in any sense, which is why abortion can be legal or illegal and neither is a constitional violation, it just isnt an area the constititon addresses very well except in vagaries.

@Pat

@Pat in early 1900s in Massachusetts people who refused too take the small pox vaccine could be fined. This was fought and went all the way up to the supreme court which rules the fine was legal and constitutional.

While I strongly disagree with this ruling, and while the spirit of the Constitution in my opinion implies this should be illegal. Sadly nothing explicit is stated and the supreme court has clearly ruled that such mandates are, sadly, legal.

I'd imagine thats far more draconian than vaccine passports, which also absolutely should be illegal, though I wouldnt argue it on explicit constitutional terms.

@icedquinn

No I literally gave multiple solutions... either you arent stupid and therefore capable of proving it through your own expertise and/or ability to evaluate the expertise of others... or you rely on the expert consensus... all of those are valid answers.

You basically said "well what if you arent an expert and dont trust experts"... thats like saying "What if someone os am idiot and beleives stupid things without evidence, what evidence can you provide them to prove it to them"... the answer is, none, if they are stupid enough to not only not be an expert but to think experts are untrustowrthy by virtue of being an expert, then they are too stupid to evaluate facts at that point... let them worry about the flat earth and unicorns they cant be helped.

@kayden @bluejay

@icedquinn

I am not suggesting you trust the peer reviewers simply by being peer reviewers... you look at the history of the peer reviewers, the history of the publishers, and the history of the journal, and judge accordingly.

@kayden @bluejay

@icedquinn

Well a person cant test it themselves because they arent intelligent to know how even if they had the equipment... even a court case would be trusting experts. If the government said "sure ill prove it to you" and brought a vial of it to the court case, what then? It would require an expert to verify it... you'd still be relying on an expert.

It is literally impossible not to rely on an expert, or be an expert yourself.

But when 100% of credible experts all agree and 0% of them find contradiction, then you either need to accept what the experts say, learn to become an expert yourself, or be an idiot who believes in unfounded conspiracy theories... there isnt a 4th option.

@kayden @bluejay

@icedquinn

Link to the case your talking about. If they actively tried to isolate it and found they couldnt, then lied, that would be damning.

@kayden @bluejay

@icedquinn

You look for both, we already have countless proof positives in all the credibly written papers that have isolated it independently. The lack of a single paper failing to do so also gives a lack of negative proof.

@kayden @bluejay

@bluejay

isolate implies it is not in vivo.. you cant isolate it if its in the body, its only isolated when you have it in a test tube seperate from the body and concentrated.

@icedquinn @kayden

@icedquinn

Review the journals where isolation was attempted and see if there are any credible publications from established experts where they concluding that the COVID virus could not be isolated.

Hint: While you will find countless experiments successfully isolating COVID you wont find a single one that concluded they were unable to isolate COVID.

@kayden @bluejay

@icedquinn

It is only "weird" if you watch some concervative conspiracy theory discredited media that describes the case in a way that isnt remotely accurate.

When you actually review the case there is nothing remotely weird about it. The man wasnt suing the government and demanding an isolate, he was being fined and when he attempted to demand an isolate that had no relevance to the case in question of any kind, the court threw out his request as not being relevant to the case.

So it makes perfect sense and nothing remotely odd about it. So anyone who actually bothers to think there is some legitimacy to it is either watching conspiracy theory nonsense and repeating it or just is clueless himself.

@kayden @bluejay

@icedquinn If you mean the king case in alberta it did not go down at all like you described... Which is the only case I could think you might mean.

@icedquinn

National health authorities, depending on whom you are refering, dont necceseraly have isolates on hand. Nor would they necceseraly be obligated to provide it, depending on the reasoning.

Who exactly was sued, and under what conditions was it refused.. be specific cite the situation and we can discuss.

@kayden @bluejay

@icedquinn

Can you list even a single case where a scientist who claimed to isolate it was required under subponea to provide proof od isolation and couldnt?

@kayden @bluejay

@icedquinn

The government has nothing to do with it. Countless of scientists, non government related, have isolated covid and produced reports about it. The fact that the government isnt cooperative in any respect is hardly evidence of that.

So yea that one is completely absurd.

@kayden @bluejay

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.