Show newer

@adidal

We have in fact tried quite a few flavors of communism. There are atleast 12 or 13 countries I can think of off hand which were non-marxist communisms.

Consider the over 100 different communist countries we have tried over the years, and in many different "flavors" and forms, all of which effectively failing, I think its pretty safe to say its a deadend.

Now if you want to try a non-communist country that you think should be considering communist but isnt because it doesnt meet the definition, then I might be more forgiving in my opinion of that. We would have to discuss the details. But I would never consider those communist myself.

@realcaseyrollins

@adidal

Neither definition is completely limited to the marxist-leninst model, but it will rule out some governments as falling under the definition, and rightfully so.

The thing about definitions is they arent meant to be "rewritten" just because you want something to be communist that isnt. The truth is if the definition doesnt describe something as communist, then it isnt communist, and we shouldnt be rewriting definitions to change that.

Its a semantic discussion, but still an important one. Its why we can actually make useful statements about ommunism and not expect those statements to become useless just because the definition is a moving target. Redefining communism serves no useful purpose as I can see it.

@realcaseyrollins

@adidal

"shared property" is not the definition of communism. Communism is most commonly defined as a system of government where the means of production **and** the means of consumption is controlled.

Contrast this with socialism where only the means of production is controlled.

The definition of "shared property" isnt particularly necessary given the formal definitions.

@realcaseyrollins

@Hyolobrika Perhaps :) Though if everyone is mature about it then the issue is resolved by just asking and clarifying, just as we did. When people act like adults things tend to resolve themselves fairly well.

@zleap yea very true, and often true of most mainstream media honestly.

@adidal

Indeed. But their moral compass is less of a concern for me than the fact that the shared property of communism is a harmful factor (in my opinion) to the quality of their proposed governments.

@realcaseyrollins

@zleap Hacked is a very strong word. The dude literally just typed in the standard signup link which had been removed from the main page... Its not hacking, its stupidity on the site maintainers part, nothing more.

According to the daily mail the new trump social media site was hacked and fake profiles created

dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1

if this is based on Mastodon, is this an older version or are there some genuine security concerns here that can affect other instances.

@realcaseyrollins on second look perhaps its less obvious than I first thought. One would have to calculate the actual slopws here to really say I suppose. It also isnt the best graph considering it is cut off a bit too early anyway.

@adidal

While it is certainly true there are many fgorms of communism, but definition being a communism ensures you have a very specific set of properties, and you **must** have this to qualify as a communism.

Therefore it is perfectly reasonable to say, and in my opinion correct, that any of the many flavors, if they happen to have the properties needed to qualify as communist, then that quality will ultimately lead to a much worse economy and quality of life than if that communistic property were not present.

@realcaseyrollins

@realcaseyrollins You are looking at the GDP, thats the wrong thing, you need to look at the rate of change of the GDP, the slow of the lines not their position.

@realcaseyrollins I am of the opinion that communism generally fails both economically and in terms of personal freedoms.

In the charts I provided you can clearly see that the rate of increase int he GDP is significantly higher post-communism than pre-communism for most of those countries.

@stux She is thinking right now "holy shit vampires are real and I just turned into one!"

@realcaseyrollins Perhaps, this is largely why I asked you what the indicators should be and then provided whatever that was.

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.