Show newer

@Pat Except that in reality it isnt helping anyone, thats the problem. Money distribution never does. It only gives the illusion of it. The act of redistributing wealth dissolves the wealth, in other words, when you take it out of investments and into people who are not historically responsible spenders its the same as burning money, prices go up, and ultimately long term doesnt just negate the UBI but puts people in a worse position than when it started.

In fact you can see that off recent data from america where checks were given out to everyone as a sort of UBI for COVID.. almost to the date the checks were sent out prices on the items people were buying with those checks skyrocketed and it wasnt until that money was all spent that prices normalized again.

UBI is the best way to ensure the collective wealth is destroyed and everyone is left worse off than before. Like i said it only works when you forget the fact that wealth is in constant flux and 1$ isnt the same one day to the next.

@vulgate No wrong. You seem to think "doing things to make money" somehow equates to capitalism, it doesnt. Again by definition if you have slavery you dont have capitalism. Things that literally cant by definition exist together can not be twins.

The fact that your argument is so weak you have to resort to name calling pretty much proves my point.

Good day, please dont contact me again. I prefer to deal with respectful people.

@Pat No people buying luxury things is junk as well. But thats just it, wealthy people do buy luxury things but generally its a VERY small percentage of what they buy. The vast majority of rich people got there not by wasting money but by investing and using a small portion of that to buy luxury things. It just looks like a lot because they have so much, but in terms of percentage of their income its quite small usually. If a rich person was wastefully spending on luxury in terms of being the majority of their income they would have never gotten rich.

Keep in mind rich people who got rich through luck or means other than investment, like some musicians can be the exception rather than the rule.

However poor people generally spend much much higher percentage of their income on "junk" relative to the percentage they invest. In fact most poor or middle class people are wasting their money on cars, fancy shoes, or expensive phones and leave little if any for investment. So their ratio of waste is quite high usually.

As for it all being worth exactly what the market says its worth... worth is not the same as wealth. If I buy brand new shoes for 200$, yes it is worth that... new. The moment I put them on my feet it now drops to being worth what, 50$. That is 150$ that literally goes up in smoke in an instant. So buying those overpriced shoes means you are destroying wealth, not creating it. Buy a stock for 200$ though and while your buying something of the exact same worth it is very unlikely to drop 75% in a day. Yes you might loose money but that is balanced by the fact that you might gain money as well. So it is where the wealth generation lies ultimately.

As for using it to start a business or get an education... well putting aside UBI isnt nearly enough to pay for those things, yes some will. But they will be a small minority. Instead of giving people millions or billions in cash and seeing 0.1% of them use it to tip the scales to go off to college you'd be better served to just use taxes to make college free for everyone. Then you know 100% of that money is going to actually improve someones skills and therefore long term generate real wealth from that money.

"To the mind that is still the whole universe surrenders" - Lao Tzu

@vulgate *looks at the whole history of communism from Russia/USSR to Northern Korea*

Sure thing bud

Side note, slavery is not capitalism, it is the opposite of capitalism. That is **not** a free market a free market is when people arent slaves and are actually.. wait for it... free.

@Pat yea my example was facetious.

As I said earlier concentration of wealth is not an issue as it doesnt reduce the participants as you suggest. Wealth is counter intuitive because the second you start thinking of it as a fixed value that can be redistributed at all is when you fail (IMO) to understand it.

When you distribute the wealth artificially the wealth effectively evapoates because you have pushed the wealth from investment vehicles (what the wealthy mostly do with it) to non-interest bearing assets, largely things which have little or no resale value, at least in part. You effectively move the wealth out of investments designed to generate wealth and into designer shoes, or new video games and other things which have little or no value. The companies make some profit off of it, so the wealth doesnt disappear entierly. But ultimately it does far more harm than good.

People buying lots of junk is not a healthy economy. People investing in companies and using a small portion of wealth generated to buy some luxury things is fine however. Thats why when the wealthy have a lot of money, at least in a healthy society, it generates the most wealth and indirectly creates the most prosperity for the people (who tend to share in the profit from these ventures via their 401K or even as an employee by it producing more jobs).

@ringo

Tht depends. If society cares about community then they will favor stores that are community minded. As such a capitalism where the culture of the society is communal will itself naturally take on a communal tone.

@mathlover @iankenway

@Pat UBI sounds like a wonderful idea. My proposal for an UBI implementation is where we take 75% of the money from every worker's pay check and give it with no conditions asked backed to their employer. That way the employer has more money to pay wages with and naturally will give everyone a raise!

Thanks everyone for 500 followers! Really blessed and humbled.

Crazy number since there are others posting way better content than me who have fewer followers than I do

@agora_brewing

I would say no myself. Ideologically pure communism or capitalism has never existed and can not exist. Ideologically pure ideas themselves simply cant exist because the world is far too nuanced. It becomes self-contradictory if you refine the ideas too much.

At best we can have these ideas as central tenants and we may refer to that as capitalism or communism and we just ignore the fact that it isnt "pure" for the same reason we dont expect something to be absolute zero.

@raucao

@Pat

Yea the issues I saw existed long before the pandemic. It seemed to start around 911 onward where fear in general became the typical message from the government.

And yea my experience with central Europe in anecdotal at best.

@roboneko @vulgate

@Pat

This is very true. Though the immorality of the americans isnt about tight resources or lack of wealth, there is more than enough of that going around (though there are issues with it like any nation).

The mental health issues are more about lack of health care that covers mental health, taboos around mental health, and how people are raised. It is a cultural thing mostly accelerated by bad policies in healthcare that prevent access to therapy, which is already far enough behind the curve simply due to the negative image associated with it.

@roboneko @vulgate

@Pat

I will say this outside of the USA there is a much larger portion of decent people. English speaking non-USA countries tend to still have a lot of ick to it but its miles ahead of the USA in terms of decent people... Though I do find central europe to be some of the best people around in terms of being ethically mindful, not that the rest of europe is that far behind.

@roboneko @vulgate

@Pat

Its not the news I am judging the ratio of good people on. Its my personal expiernce.

The USA is like a country wide mental hospital. Almost everyone in it is suffering from such severe mental disorders that no one really has the capacity to be good people.

@roboneko @vulgate

@Pat

I disagree. In america **most** people take advantage. It is just that most of them really want to appear like good people, even to themselves, so they either only do so when they wont get caught, or come up with crazy justifications why what they did is perfectly ok... Very very few people in the USA I have known have turned out to be good people when no one is watching in the long run.

@roboneko @vulgate

@roboneko

There are plenty of perverse incentives that lead to exploitation and corrupting, but none of this is inherent to capitalism and are in fact counter to capitalism.

Ther eis no shortage of exploitation in communism either as we have seen from past governments that are built around this concept.

The fact is people are shitty and no matter what form of government you have people will exploit it and when they do it ceases to be a government built on the ideals of those principles. We need to stop blaming the principles that in their own regard are good in moderation and start realizing people are just shit and will take advantage any time they have power.

@vulgate

@realcaseyrollins

I'm glad you did. I found it interesting, though I cant relate in the slightest, which I suppose is why its interesting. I do enjoy learning how people think regarding things I cant relate to.

@adidal @Marbleturtle

@realcaseyrollins

Nothing against your sister or furries but honestly I would never expected you to have a sister as a furry.

@adidal @Marbleturtle

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.