Show newer

@hellomiakoda and as long as we are blaming parrty members for presidential failures lets not forget that democrats spent the whole time after the virus was released assembling in mass crowds to protest and burn shit down... You know whats worse for a pandemic than not wearing masks? Garthering in large crowds.

@hellomiakoda Also lets not forget those people not wearing masks were around when trump was around too... so despite that being nothing new Biden saw a larger increase in the prevalence of the virus than trump... its almost like its not about the masks but his ineptitude (not that trump was particularly competent or anything, he wasn't).

@hellomiakoda In fact if you really want to go there; the number of people who are middle class or below who illegally dont pay taxes or report income (people who work under the table) are far far more numerous than the number of millionaires who dont pay taxes.

Maybe its the middle class who should "pay taxes for once"

@hellomiakoda
The rich already pay taxes, and a lot of it. I care because the rich are vital to an economy and when they are over taxed we all suffer

@Pat Admin costs would be there, and it would be less, but ultimately the deal breaker for me is that free money is not the form of help they need most. Unconditional money never works, which is why the current welfare system doesnt work well either. You want simpler, here is simple:

No welfare of any kind in the usual sense. If you bring in a bill and grades showing you passed any educational program (inluding certifications and trade schools) then the government will give you 1.5x the cost in cash... Free education, the money they get is contigent on them building skills, and now they are about to generate wealth on their own. Not the system I'd employ but if you want simple with little to no bureaucracy then thats the way to do it. If they want free money they need to demonstrate they are using it correctly.

@Pat yea so now youve ruined the advantges of a UBI to the point it doesnt resemble one at all. You now need administration since there is a means test in place , and it isnt universal either more generally.

Plus the cost is just off the charts anyway... i cant support anything about a UBI even when its an actual UBI, let alone this.

@sapphire

Right you have the option to file, if you want or if it benefits you. But you do not have to file. Many of the people in poverty do not file as they either dont work or get paid under the table.

@Pat

@sapphire

The minimum ammount needed to file a tax return with the irs is 12,500, below that you need not file at the end of the year.

@Pat

@Pat So now ther eis an application test, a means test, and a team that needs to somehow verify their income... There is nothing remotely resembling UBI at this point.

@Pat People in poverty do not file taxes and owe no money in tax. Therefore they are not in the IRS system. So it cant work for your intended purpose.

@Pat if they are sending checks through the tresury system then that is administrative costs. Someone needs to manage that system, send out the checks, handle cases for appeal, etc.

Also keep in mind the 20% poorest people usually dont need to file taxes at all. so the vast majority of those people wont be in the system.

@Pat If you arnt checking a persons income level yet setting it below 20% then how are you ensureing the people who are actually below 20% are the ones getting it? Someone who is middle class would be more than happy to get $1000 free a month if they are just handing them out.

For that matter if there is no administration how do you even ensure a single person can collect a check multiple times.

collecting taxes that way doesnt change the numbers at all.. It still means they would have to pay upwards of 10% of their total income to support it. It just means your getting that money from their income but rather sales tax or whatever else you get it from. Your taking the same amount of money out of their pocket (10% of their income) regardless of how you play with the numbers.

So the fact is your still reducing everyones effective income by 10%.

Sorry but worst idea ever.. 10% is huge to support a system that ultimately only enables the poor and does nothing to get them out of poverty.

@Pat We have gotten tot he point where the semantics are just too polluted.. You are still calling it a UBI and arguing that it avoids administrative costs, but then effectively not implementing a UBI at all and only giving it to the 20% lowest class of society, which means you havent avoided the administrative costs at all, your back to needing a means test and all the administration of traditional ways. So right off the bat you destroyed the one argument for UBI you could have had."

Second redefining tax as being on all money passing hands and increasing the taxable number figure 10 fold only serves to make the percentage appear lower when in fact its still costing the average american in dollars and cents the same amount in taxes as if 10% were taxed witht he current system.. .so while it create a nice small number by the sound of it in reality it changed nothing. You are still talking about taking 10% out of everyones income to support it, 5% if you dont do UBI at all and just target the 20% poor but then that 5% goes back up since its not a UBI and you have admin costs so its probably closer to 7% or 8% of everyones entire income to pay for it. Getting the tax from other means doesnt lower the amount of tax coming out of peoples pockets so that is a moot and confusing distortion of the situation.

@Pat That would be an improvement over a UBI. But I dont think it will solve the problem. Throwing money at problems blinding almost never solve problems.

I'm usually all for minimal government and simple is usually the way to go. But I've seen sooooo many in poverty waste money in some of the worst ways that I just cant support sending them a blank check. I just dont think money is what people in poverty need to get out of poverty nearly as much as education, skill training, and access to mental health. None of which do people in poverty tend to spend their money on except for a small percentage.

@Pat by the way to be clear discretionary budget is not the complete spending of the USA. I used it because its usually what people talk about.

If we talk about full spending of the USA government then its around 6.5 trillion a year. So a $400 UBI at a cost of 1.7 trillion plus whatever the administration costs would be be at a cost equivelant to 1/4or 25% of **all** spending of the us government in a year.. again this is absolutely insantely expensive.

@Pat Let me put this another way. The entier discretionary budget of the USA in 2015 was 1.11 trillion. The cost not including administrative cost for $400 UBI is 1.7 trillion. Significantly more than the entire discretionary budget of the USA.

I'm not sure you realize just how **massive** an expense UBI is... You would nearly have to double **all** taxes collected int he USA. On average people pay about 13% tax across all forms of tax in the usa.. a 10% increase is nearly doubling that.

UBI is far from "a few percentage points"... it is an absolutely phenomenal expense.

@louisrcouture

Yea they could. But these kids know the brands and the specific makes. There is usually one very specific brand and model of shoe that is the cool one that month and people know full well if you bought that one or some cheaper model.

That said the shoes are even just one example. I have seen countless examples of bad money management not just from those in poverty but even just the lower-middle class and middle class in some cases. At least in america. Everyone buys a house 3x bigger than they need or own more cars then they need. Very few people outside of the well-to-do have anything that approaches good money management skills honestly.

@Pat

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.