So I will soon be (hopefully) diving the great blue hole in egypt. This has a depth of around 60 meters to get to the arch. Sadly my current camera is rated only to 50 meters.
Who among you would care enough to see me dive the blue hole archway out into the sea enough to make it worth me upgrading my camera?
@namark My assertion was about both contradiction and agreeing in a sense. On the one hand I pointed out that with some classes of problems what you described to be true (And thus in line with your expiernces). Yet with other classes of problems you are incorrect. This was my argument from the get go.
So my point was always about your stance as an absolutism is incorrect but can be true situationally.
If we are really going to be critical of the meta-argument where you seem to be talking now I'd say my stance has more common ground to connect to (not being an absolutism and all) than your own. That said I personally dont find such metadiscussion useful beyond reflecting on how we can communicate better in the future.
@Parienve It is sadly all too common. It is a particularly common tactic in extreme conservative and liberal circles where public opinion seems to be of high importance, as well as following witht he majority. Questioning the stance of either group, even as a member will get you a lot of ire.
@mc note that the ambiguity only arrises with "division with a slash" which is the wording used even in the exceptions to the general rule such as the journal mentioned.
@mc yup, well aware of the wikipedia article. Been over it countless times with people on this debate.
@namark ::rolls eyes:: its not about bragging. I shared my experience for the same reason as you, because it contradicts your claims much as you feel your experience contradicts mine. My goal in mentioning this is no more empirical than your own. Simply put, I've seen for myself that your claims have been wrong in countless projects, that experience has value, experience is hard to objectify, so take it as you will.
Either way I see you've reached that point as you always do in conversations where your own obnoxiousness outweights any ability to have an adult conversation. I'll be muting this conversation now, have a good day.
@Parienve I find the more subtle forms of ad baculum to be the most insidious. Yea the whole "Your an idiot ill kill you" if you dont agree with someone makes it impossible to take them seriously. But thankfully its so absurd I dont even consider it here.
The worse form of it goes something like this:
"I support providing therapy for people with inappropriate sexual urges so they dont act on it."
them: "Oh so you are a pedophile sympathizer, I'm sure you are real popular with the ladies"
Basically implying that the whole of society will hate you for your viewpoint, as if how much you are liked somehow effects what the truth is.
@namark If your reaching the point in a project where memory issues wind up costing significant investment of time late in a project then the project either picked the wrong language or simply doesnt have good programmers.
My job is more often than not to get called in to write or fix software that the current less expiernced team is not capable of making performant on their own. Sometimes that means I need to rewrite it in C, but this is very rare. More often than not the problems arise from bad design choices from the start of the problem and are easily fixed with the right expiernce without the investment of time you suggest.
That said my own projects are ones that rely on being extremely efficient as a purpose of their design (for example Aparapi's whole point is GPU accelerating java code , so efficiency is paramount). In all these cases performance was done right from the get go and the problems you describe never arose. Yes I would profile and sometimes need to optimize. But this process was always a relatively easy and short process.
So my assumption is that either your own expiernce was simply lacking in the languages you had this problem in, and you made poor design choices, or your team was making poor choices. Not the language itself.
As an example a national trucking company with tens of thousands of trucks on the road across the USA called me in to optimize their system. It was mostly graph optimization problems (think traveling salesman sort of stuff), so extremely sensitive to memory management and other efficiency issue. Their current software written in C was massive and ran across an entire server room about about 50 computers on racks. I was able to improve the rate at which it computed solutions by 10 fold and reduce the number of computers from 50 down to 1 (though there was 1 or 2 extra for redundancy, but these were idle for the most part). Best part yet it was written in a combination of Ruby and Java in the end, both memory management languages.
I can easily count the amount of times that teams of programers overs years were incapable of making a system efficient in C that I was effortless able to replace with memory managed languages that did the same task many of orders of magnitude faster. All while doing it in a fraction of the development time that the C programmers invested.
That said I can also count the number of times the reverse is true, that I used C to replace a memory managed language and was able to achieve an improvement in performance as well.
I'm not sure I'd use the word clever, unless your british as it would fit the way they use the word clever. But I would call them good things that you do.
@matrix I can honestly say he managed to eliminate every single enemy he came across.
The one thing that will never surprise me is when people do stupid things... I am more surprised when they do something intelligent.
Well remains to be seen if they did anything stupid.. Like if they actually stole the diary, then yea, they could face some real trouble I suppose. But they also could be innocent. Who know, the evidence isnt exactly public.
@twotwenty Its not the truth im sorry for, im just sorry the pfizer CEO didnt get arrested, that sounds like it would be a fun turn of events to debate :)
@freemo dont be sorry for the truth.
Sure, but we arent talking about the wage, we are talking about the notion that you need to love your job.. im arguing most people dont, supermarkets or otherwise.
Also to be fair I've never seen lower wages than I did when I tried to work int he netherlands. They would offer me about 1/6th the wage I would get in america for my job.
@namark How many years did you spend coding Java exactly? It may be your experience being opposite comes down to the fact that you never gained sufficient experience with the language. While it takes less effort than C to get right, it does take an equal amount of understanding and experience.
For example your talking about spending too much time optimizing in a garbage collection language... if you have the need to optimize your memory management beyond the direct and expected ways of the language then you shouldnt be using that language, thats the point... **most** of the time you shouldnt need to optimize for memory in a convoluted way, the expected ways are more than sufficient and dont create bottlenecks. When that stops being true is when you should probably be at a lower level.
The notion that you only need to optimize memory in C in exceptional situations is far from reality. AS stated if you use it out of the box memory waste is **Extreme** in C.. for example apps like perl and ghostscript written in C that dont optimize the memory system beyond the out of the box use of malloc expiernce about 40% of their run time dealing with allocating and deallocating memory. The same app written in Java would have no where near that load even if no optimization on memory was done beyond the usual normal good practices.
Marginal slowdowns also dont just "add up", the problem is not that simple. If your memory system is 0.1% slower, for example, but your bottleneck is in the processor (and that bottleneck is not due to inefficiency but the difficult of the task itself) then that 0.1% or even a 10% slowdown in memory will have noe ffect on runtime at all since despite the memory access being slower it can complete before the processing queue is complete and thus never effects runtime.
The line of thinking your using usually leads people do to what is called "premature optimization" which has the counterintuitive effect of often **slowing down** your code rather than speeding it up by optimizing code that is not contributing to a bottleneck, and thus introducing more chances for human error in your code.
@trinsec Cartoons are way more educational than people give them credit for :)
I'm not sure calling it a temp job when it lasts for years is doing the conversation much justice. Most people will switch jobs every so many years through their life. Its rare a person sticks with one company for a life time. Do we call them all temp jobs just because they dont last until you die?
Jeffrey Phillips Freeman
Innovator & Entrepreneur in Machine Learning, Evolutionary Computing & Big Data. Avid SCUBA diver, Open-source developer, HAM radio operator, astrophotographer, and anything nerdy.
Born and raised in Philadelphia, PA, USA, currently living in Utrecht, Netherlands, USA, and Thailand. Was also living in Israel, but left.
Pronouns: Sir / Mister
(Above pronouns are not intended to mock, i will respect any persons pronouns and only wish pronouns to show respect be used with me as well. These are called neopronouns, see an example of the word "frog" used as a neopronoun here: http://tinyurl.com/44hhej89 )
A proud member of the Penobscot Native American tribe, as well as a Mayflower passenger descendant. I sometimes post about my genealogical history.
My stance on various issues:
Education: Free to PhD, tax paid
Abortion: Protected, tax paid, limited time-frame
Welfare: Yes, no one should starve
UBI: No, use welfare
Racism: is real
Guns: Shall not be infringed
LGBT+/minorities: Support
Pronouns: Will respect
Trump: Moron, evil
Biden: Senile, racist
Police: ACAB
Drugs: Fully legal, no prescriptions needed
GPG/PGP Fingerprint: 8B23 64CD 2403 6DCB 7531 01D0 052D DA8E 0506 CBCE