Show newer

@Hyolobrika@berserker.town

You may defederate for several reasons other than intolerance:

* dont have resources to host a full node
* arent hosting a general social media server but rather one for a private network or for a specific topic
* compliance with regional laws
* to prevent spammy/botnet/rogue nodes
* only want to connect to Tor nodes
* cut off servers that engage in DoS attacks/flooding
* cut off servers where users are allowed to circumvent individual users private bans by allowing users to host many accounts explicitly to counteract private account-level bans

@straw @r000t

@Hyolobrika@berserker.town

Yes, I see a few flaws. Your premise is wrong and on top of that it isnt mutually exclusive. not all defederation is out of intolerance, and not all federation is tolerance. We are talking about a single group that uses it in those ways is all,

@straw @r000t

@Hyolobrika@berserker.town

They cant satisfy the condition in reality, doesnt stop them from trying.

@straw @r000t

@Hyolobrika@berserker.town

Federating also doesnt mean "tolerates". Having access to information doesnt mean you tolerate it, it only means you are capable of seeing it. If i can see hateful things it doesnt imply i tolerate hateful things.

@straw @r000t

@straw

Federating != liking

Think of it this way: "I dont like nazis, therefore I wont talk to anyone who uses googles because you can search for nazi stuff on google"

@Hyolobrika@berserker.town @r000t

@Hyolobrika@berserker.town

Its flawed logic obviously, but that doesnt stop them from promoting it.

@straw @r000t

@straw

no it has nothing to do with seeing the content. If your server blocks GAB and you federate with an instance that associates with GAB, then you as a server still cant see GAB, even if a user from over there were to boost the content from GAB you wouldnt see it. So clearly the motivation goes beyond not wanting to see GAB content. The point is to take the voice away from GAB so **others** cant see it

@Hyolobrika@berserker.town @r000t

@Hyolobrika@berserker.town

It isnt practical, but its a pretty common mentality. For a short while all fediverse apps were pulled from the google store due to the moderation dynamics on the fedi, luckily it was short lived and the community fraught back mostly.

@r000t

@straw

Then you havent been on the fedi long. The isolate GAB movement is a prime example. People werent just content with being on servers that moderated GAB, they demanded they only federate with servers that themselves blocked GAB, and that they do the same. Effectively dictating how other servers federated and not just the content a server itself produced.

@Hyolobrika@berserker.town @r000t

@Hyolobrika@berserker.town

No but destroying the fediverse and anything like it and only having monolithic entities with gatekeepers that censor all but the most acceptable of ideas does, as if such a thing were possible. But pull it from google play and the istore, pull it from google search results, censor access to the whole network.. its a dark rabbit hole

@r000t

@Hyolobrika@berserker.town

The thing about people who hate free speech (and there are a lot) is that they arent upset that they need to **hear** speech they dislike, they are upset that other people are able to hear it (or say it for that matter).

So while it may seem a reasonable solution to me or you for them to just go to a moderated instance in their eyes it isnt fixing the issue that there are unmoderated servers out there.

@r000t

@Hyolobrika@berserker.town

The same as the arguments for it :)

@r000t

aaaaalmost there..... you're thiiiiis fucking close to it.....

@estebanz01 Had to abort the dive due to technical issues that would have jeopardized my safety/

@hans
Maybe i had too much to drink but cant follow qhat your saying

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.