Show newer

@PiedraFiera Whicjh is my point. If we use that logic then it is perfectly ok for mothers to murder their children for the first several years of life as well. So the logic seems to break down the moment you try to apply it.

@PiedraFiera You have memories as a fetus? I doubt you remember what level of awareness you had at all, let alone that you lacked a sense of self.

@PiedraFiera So since fetuses are effected by abortion then they should get to decide. How do we enable a fetus to decide? If we argue that they dont get a say because they cant decide then we must likewise allow the murder of any baby for any reason prior to about the age of 4 - 6 (at which point they might be able to make some decision). The logic breaks down quickly.

In my eyes it isnt so complex or even subjective. The goal should be to minimize suffering. The suffering of the fetus needs as much consideration as that of the mother. There is room for disagreement there, but once we agree that the goal is to minimize suffering then most everything eelse falls into place.

@freemo
You get to the knot of the problem. There are no objective criteria. Different criteria can be set up to serve different ends.
The protection of the fetus is a criteria in itself, that justifies control over people's lives.
If the well being of fetus was the issue, maternal health would be the priority, and that would go beyond pregnancy, it would justify providing free healthcare and other services for all. Institutions complicit with such high rates of maternal death, that normalize access to health restricted to those that can pay, only hypocritically care about the fetus.

@PiedraFiera Yes we must first agree that murdfer is wrong, once that criteria is set then it can be quite objective in what achieves that goal and what does not.

I stated in my OP that many aspects of helathcare must be free for any resolution to be had. So I agree on that regard, healthcare must be a priority along with any decisions made about abortion

@PiedraFiera No brrain cells does not garuntee self-awareness or any sort of complex thought. It **does** represent some degree of cognition however. They produce signals and process data.

The point is **no one** can define the moment that life becomes smart enough that all of a sudden it has rights. Trying to define it leads to the slippery slope where people with mental disorders are assumed to not have any more rights that a cow, which doesnt work.

What brain cells mean is it is the begining of the grey area. Without brain cells we can say with certainy there is no awarness of any kind. Once brain cells are present any certainty goes out the window.

So picking a 15 week period seems to be the best all around (assuming the above considerations from my last post). It ensures the woman has a right to abortion and a window with which to decide it. It also assures the fetus has a right to life as well.

As for states control over someones body, that is inevitable no matter what side you sit on. If you are pro-abortion the state is deciding its ok to violate the fetuses right to its own body, if you are anti-abortion you are violating the mother's right. by allowing a 15 week window neither right is violated.

@icedquinn Yes I agree, there is a problem there and both sides tend to exploit it when they can.

@icedquinn I wouldnt go that far. A judges job is (or at least should be) to interpret the law. The issue is they often go to far and go beyond mere interpretation.

@icedquinn Yup, as I explicitly stated this would need to be an amendment.

@realcaseyrollins The line where it becomes murky IMO is once brain cells start forming and there is some degree of cognition. 15 weeks is about where that plays out.

Dollar pregnany tests arent enough. If we want to grossly restrict a woman's window for abortions we must also provide all the tools to make sure any woman, regardless of income, has the ability to detect pregnancy eary and act on it as she wishes.

My thoughts on the overrulling of Roe v. Wade

Generally speaking I do think the overrulling was a bad idea **as is**. Ideally if we kept abortion protections at the federal level it should have never existed as a simple supreme court precedence. I would be all for overturning the supreme court ruling and instead replacing it with an actually amendment protecting abortions.

That said any such amendment I would also leave to be pretty loose. Namely I'd be ok with any bans/restrictions on abortions post 15 weeks conception but prior to that abortions should be strictly permitted. In addiction I'd make it a requirement that all abortions <15 weeks after contraception **must** be performed regardless if the person can pay for it up front or not. We would also need to make access to pregnancy tests free.

Since I dont see the above happening I cant in my right mind support the overturning of roe v wade, as much as I do prefer reducing federal laws and oversight... this one is just too close to a violation of natural rights to me.

@biomedmax I think the server is for fans of a certain podcast or something stupid. But yea, they all strongly encourage a pretty similar mindset there, and its an ugly one for sure

@cwebber

There was a stock increase, that isnt the same as saying the layoffs are the **cause** of the stock increase. In general the stock would increase if the decision made is best for the company in the opinion of the public. If the public thinks a recession is going to happen then a layoff will likely increaase the stock, otherwise it will likely decrease it.

So if anything this probably isnt showing so much that a stock increase will generally follow layoff but rather that whenn a recession is looming a layoff is going to have the best impact on share price, but otherwise may be detrimental.

@timorl

@rastinza

To be fair I often dont lock the house when im in the middle of a city in the USA with a high crime rate either :)

The way I see it no one is going around jiggling door handles to rob houses in the middle of the day. If they are going to rob your house they likely just break a window and a door lock isnt much, if any, of a deterrent.

@trinsec

@trinsec in the netherlands for me UPS would often leave the package unattended without permission but would go out of their way to hide it. for example they would often walk into my backyard and leave it near the backdoor.

That said I had some truly weird interactions. More than once, without permission, the UPS guy just walked into the house and left it on our table while we werent there.

@trinsec It is probably different depending on the country. In the USA leaving it unattended is the norm except when the person shipping specifies otherwise.

@trinsec Were they just doing it to reduce the chance of it being stolen you think?

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.