At this point I'm not even sure what you're trying to disagree with.
You've acknowledged the problem @peterbutler brought up!
Instances like qoto.org have effectively no limit on character counts. Well, technically something like 65,500 characters.
But yep, other Fediverse platforms are specifically targeted at blog type posts that do share over to Mastodon and others.
I don't think there's much point responding farther.
The features you're recognizing here are the exact ones that I'd say allow the platform to resist censorship, making it censorship resistant, even if you personally wouldn't apply that term.
*shrug*
Kind of like complaining that corporate restaurants have conditioned people to expect their food to be served cooked instead of having them take the one simple step of cooking it themselves, and what's the problem here?
Yep. People do like when the platforms they join provide them value. Heaven forbid.
In any case, this all just highlights that @peterbutler 's point was absolutely a thing, even if you personally prefer the problem to exist.
Yes, but can either post to Fediverse?
So if there isn't a universally accepted definition of Censorship Resistance, you're being awfully definitive in saying Nostr doesn't offer it :)
It looks like Nostr provides alternative ways of accessing content, routing around points of potential censorship, along with built in methods for automatically routing as more relays are added.
You might not personally think that's enough resistance for your own comfort, but it IS resistance to censorship.
It does have some value, whether you think it's a great value or a small value.
and I just came across a post from someone complaining about this very issue.
I'm glad you posted this because I was just having an exchange with someone denying that this problem exists.
When telling people to run their own instances, this downside is being overlooked.
I suspect this is not possible as it would fall under the "no quote tweet" policy that the Mastodon developers decided to adopt.
Other Fediverse platforms could have it, though.
And it's yet another reason I think Mastodon needs to reverse that development decision.
(Preface: obviously I have criticisms here :) so this is going to be just my little rant)
I think it channels the Twitter philosophy of being a mindless firehose where it doesn't matter what you miss because you're just expected to be having knee jerk reactions to the latest two sentence comment.
With the character limit, the content was expected to be so vapid that it really didn't matter what you missed: the algorithm would provide you something to react to there at the top, and its not like you were going to miss real information about the world in what happened to scroll by.
I criticize #Mastodon for maintaining much of what made #Twitter kind of awful, and I hope people explore other #Fediverse interfaces that are more useful and healthy.
Instances I've looked into have a preference option for a slow mode where things don't autoload.
Yes, you listed one step to respond to the problem. Because it's a problem. :)
The reason it's not a fundamental human right is because it implies a right to require someone else to work for you against their own interests.
It implies a right to another person's labor, which is not a right I would recognize; certainly it's a right that is generally rejected in cultures around the world these days.
But on #Fediverse in particular, the ability to join instances with a diversity of policies, and respecting that diversity, objects to that sort of blanket statement about rules to which people must conform as they express themselves.
This platform is built on diversity, not conformance.
I'd just highlight how your laying out a solution to the problem illustrates that yes, it is a real, existing problem.
So yep, as @peterbutler said, you lose visibility and there are hoops a person can jump through to partially get it back.
Whether a person has time to take advantage of that visibility is a different question.
Because we want to leave it up to users to decide how they want to run their content.
Yes! And people need to realize, and keep in mind, that #Fediverse and #Mastodon in particular don't fully decentralize social media, but rather distribute it out to many independent centers.
Personally, I think this was a missed opportunity. #ActivityPub could have done more to actually head toward that goal of decentralization.
Well, the nice thing about Fediverse is that we can decide for ourselves what core principles are in our use of the system, without anyone else insisting that their personal preferences are The Way things should be done!
altText or don't. It up to each poster posting joyfully!
I think you're missing that "censorship resistant" doesn't mean "censorship proof."
Glancing at the project, it does seem to provide additional ways to resist censorship. Exactly as claimed.
Yep, it's still subject to censorship through various means, but that doesn't mean it doesn't resist censorship.
Right, your content has less reach, but you also lose out on content being brought in naturally by fellow instance users following others in addition to whomever you follow.
Since I guess everything is political these days, I'll identify as extremely liberal but without a home in US politics.
Mainly, there's so much misinformation out there that people in society have trouble even organizing into coherent political groupings. So I'd rather not talk about politics but instead focus on information and education. Nothing else matters until the bedrock of fact is buttressed.
So: Old man yells at clouds is a famous joke from The Simpsons, and it probably fairly describes what we do when venting on social media.