It's probably in their best interests to let this drama stretch out through as many news cycles as possible.
And personally, I scroll past posts that are too short since they don't normally have anything to say.
To each his own, and empower our platforms to tailor our experiences for our needs!
@chartier I think you're looking at it the wrong way around: instead of constraining writers, empower readers!
Firstly, there aren't really corners of #Fediverse. There are instances, but it's nominally one big, integrated universe with content flowing to all corners.
But sure, for people who don't want to read long posts, have a setting to skip those in the timeline.
(Also, events are already part of the #ActivityPub standard as it is, and #Mastodon says it supports them)
Newly revealed internal communications show that Twitter, under government pressure, suppressed truthful speech about COVID-19 as "misinformation." https://reason.com/2023/01/02/under-government-pressure-twitter-suppressed-truthful-speech-about-covid-19/
My worry is exactly that people are not understanding that the theory is already wrong.
I know users are misunderstanding things like the privacy setting on posts, believing that it guarantees access only to the people according to the setting, when it doesn't. I know this because I've talked to people who were floored to hear that's not how this platform works.
If people think they have more control over their own contents, then are wrong, and they need to know they're wrong. They need to know that the security features of this system are not designed to work the way they think.
Like I said, the big example is a user deleting a post and expecting that it will be deleted entirely. Not an unreasonable expectation! But one that is just not in line with how this system works.
This has nothing to do with virality. It has to do with privacy and control over content.
Your article primarily describes civil actions, though, not ones that would entail a law requiring the government to correct lies.
Also, Trump is guilty of stuff too, but that's a different issue.
I think the important thing is how the US government behaved. I don't care much about what some private company did; but I do believe we need to hold government officials accountable for things like working to silence people promoting viewpoints they don't like, even if their abilities to actually see that through were limited.
The thing I find really interesting about your post and my reaction to it is that you frame #QT as talking about a person while I'd see it as very explicitly talking about the content.
If I quote something and expand on it, the major reference is to what was said, not the person saying it. The person is only included as an attribute, but the content takes center stage.
And to me that's the major point of QT: it takes some specific content and builds upon it in ways that can't really be done through other means.
QT isn't about the person. It's about the quote, and sort of furthering human knowledge by taking what a person has expressed to another level.
But then, I'm an academic, so that's just daily life for me :)
I think it's critical that we raise awareness of how any platform based on ActivityPub is inherently poor with privacy guarantees as that distributed platform is fundamentally reliant on different instances voluntarily respecting privacy features.
In general users need to be aware of things like post deletion being unenforceable. If you delete a post from your account, there's nothing to say other accounts won't ignore the deletion, and I think that's a big deal!
But when you talk about privacy controls for QT, everyone needs to keep in mind that all such controls on this platform are voluntary.
My point isn't to say that there's no reason to talk about this, but just to keep in mind the limits of what can be engineered here.
Well, there is no real fediverse policy other than the technical standard, but I'd say issues of expression like that are up to the person doing the expressing.
The content creator gets to create his content as he wants it to be.
I don't want to be dictating to people how they should express themselves per some policy.
I always had no use for #Twitter
Every time I dipped my toe into that platform I found it limited, constraining even, starting with its stupid character limit.
For me the appeal of #Mastodon is that it's far, far better than Twitter because of its interface to #ActivityPub / #Fediverse.
Here the platform isn't limited to exceedingly short posts, but can instead support long posts AND so much more: rich multimedia, and types of content that the standard hasn't even thought of yet.
For me the appeal of Mastodon is that it's exponentially better than Twitter ever was, empowering users and enabling forms of expression that Twitter never could match.
I think it's a HUGE problem that users won't know enough about Mastodon/Fediverse/ActivityPub to realize how this works, and they will expect exactly that deleting a post is effectively instant and guaranteed.
Users won't be aware of the technical model. They'll just be used to social media as it's always been, and assume this platform has similar behavior.
This has huge privacy implications.
FWIW, I'd rename the list from fediverse apps to fediverse platforms.
I think a lot of people would associate an app with a client running on a phone, so I had trouble finding the platform list.
But nice lists!
@hobs @blaine @Gargron Yeah, different people have different skills, and maybe @Gargron's skill is in building those features, not setting up organizations.
Me, I'd say Features in #Fediverse shouldn't be up to a single governance either.
And it's not. We're all free to build whatever we want to engage over #ActivityPub, even forking #Mastodon code if we really want to with our own features. Or using other platforms.
In short, on the whole there's a good chance Gargron SHOULD be working on features as we're already in a place of collective governance of Fediverse.
They don't make you the product.
You volunteer to be the product.
It's not that you can't stop them.
It's that you line up to take part.
Right, and the EC vote wasn't counted until January.
Messages before then happened before the vote, so the whole story is bunk, based on a misunderstanding of the US presidential election process that's all too often promoted in press reporting.
What law is that?
I find it a bit concerning how mastodon talks about their software and new features as if they exist in a vaccum. They talk about implementing a QT feature and forcing people to opt-in or not... Meanwhile the rest of the fediverse has had the QT feature since forever, including modified mastodon instances. We already have a standard, no you cant force opt-in.. .either implement it or dont, you cant force other software to block a feature just because you on your server didnt "opt-in". Its literally equivelant to a link to the original post...
Seeing as the dates on the texts were from before the election was completed, that story makes no sense.
Since I guess everything is political these days, I'll identify as extremely liberal but without a home in US politics.
Mainly, there's so much misinformation out there that people in society have trouble even organizing into coherent political groupings. So I'd rather not talk about politics but instead focus on information and education. Nothing else matters until the bedrock of fact is buttressed.
So: Old man yells at clouds is a famous joke from The Simpsons, and it probably fairly describes what we do when venting on social media.