Show newer

@joeinwynnewood @stopgopfox

How exactly do you see a program that actively transfers wealth from rich to poor as being a massive wealth transfer to the richest of the rich?

I really don't understand how you can get to your conclusion from what's in front of us.

@Npars01 @csgordon@zirk.us @Clackable@tldr.nettime.org @stopgopfox

The FairTax plan specifically addresses that by not requiring that sort of paperwork hurdle.

You guys keep bringing up all of these issues that I've heard the FairTax proponents themselves bring up and address decades ago.

@csgordon@zirk.us @Npars01 @Clackable@tldr.nettime.org @stopgopfox @Mastopoet @GreenFire

No.

The FairTax would increase the cash in peoples' pockets, so people who are in debt and are cash poor would end up with more resources to address that problem.

Remember that the FairTax also eliminates the taxes taken out of a person's paycheck, increasing their take home pay.

It would be an immediate boost to stagnant wages, since you bring that up in particular.

@Npars01

Perhaps John Oliver isn't the best source for unbiased coverage of the people he's shown such outright derision for?

Or... for anything else in particular? I mean, the guy is pretty dumb.

Funny commedian, but pretty ignorant.

@derekross

Careful: business owners might prefer to avoid things described as "wild" in their operations :)

@SacredIbis

No, the two won't be directly connected. There are many other factors going into liquidity.

That's not to say markets won't use these signals somewhat irrationally to make choices, though.

@sethcotlar

The element you're missing from your analogy is that the US takes in plenty to pay its debt obligations, so there would be no reason not to pay these regardless of whether it enters into even more borrowing.

In your analogy, your household income would be high enough to pay your obligations on the mortgage and credit card even if you decide not to take out a second mortgage.

@kkarhan @sethcotlar

The debt ceiling isn't racketeering.

It's merely the recognition that the legislative branch is the one authorized to commit to borrowing on behalf of the population it represents, and the debt ceiling is just the total amount that it's authorized in borrowing.

@Npars01

The FairTax is absolutely not a VAT, though.

The folks who proposed the idea are very critical of VAT schemes like the on in Canada for exactly the reasons you outline, and they emphasize that FairTax is substantially different from a tax like Canada's.

@_L1vY_ @csgordon@zirk.us @Npars01 @stopgopfox

The FairTax addresses that concern head on by actively mailing checks to the poor who would be otherwise hit by the regressive nature of sales taxes.

The plan would literally mail checks to poor people as a core part of its operation. That shouldn't be overlooked!

@csgordon@zirk.us

I think it's always noteworthy when someone equates not taking with giving away. It shows really fuzzy accounting, at best.

That someone might keep his own earnings isn't being given anything. They're his.

Yes, we can talk about whether to take away his earnings for good reasons like the funding of government, but it's not a giveaway to not do that.

@csgordon@zirk.us @Npars01 @Clackable@tldr.nettime.org @stopgopfox

The plan specifically doesn't require any sort of itemized proof of spending or application for rebates.

In fact, they emphasize that the idea is to get people this money *before* they actually pay the tax, and they refer to the payment as a prebate to highlight that.

@joeinwynnewood @stopgopfox

It comes across as rather naive to say that the IRS only goes after tax cheats, akin to saying the cops only arrest guilty people.

No, it's no secret that the IRS audits people from all walks of life, and heck, it's easier for them to go after folks who aren't so well off because their finances are easier to audit AND they have less resources with which to fight even erroneous claims against them.

As for redistribution, the FairTax proposal is built around regular payments covering the cost of taxation on necessities, which is the opposite, a redistribution of wealth away from the wealthy to the poor.

Too often I see people failing to mention that core pillar of the plan.

@CodexArcanum

In developed economies with modern financial systems there really is practically no concept of stationary money.

Even money sitting in a bank account isn't actually just sitting there. The account is credited the balance, but the money is being used to fund loans, and such.

Sure, velocity may increase or decrease in response to the economic environment, but even that is a dynamic process that doesn't actually care all that much what a rich person thinks.

But sure, the Laffer Curve looks at tax avoidance, but it's applicable to all forms of taxation, not just sales.

@Npars01 @Clackable@tldr.nettime.org @stopgopfox

@Npars01 @Clackable@tldr.nettime.org @stopgopfox

In theory it may be true that income taxes can be far simpler and cheaper to administer, but in practice we see that as set up, governments tend to choose income tax policies that are far from that ideal.

There's no real point in talking about ideals of either type of tax here since I'm positive governments won't be hitting that mark either way.

@csgordon@zirk.us @Npars01 @stopgopfox

Under the FairTax proposal the wealthy would have to pay a lot more in taxes even as the poor would enjoy the explicit and actively progressive move of the check they would get to help pay for essentials!

The proposal was intentionally designed to help the poor. Whether it's good or not, we should not pretend it is something it's not, and ignore that.

@mempko

No, the Constitution gives Congress the authority to authorize the minting of money without any requirements that it be associated with any loans.

So it's just outright just factually false that debt is required for the US to make money.

The federal government is free to make all the money at once out of thin air without any debt involved.

@TJ1001

Trading goods and services for money is not robbery.
It's exactly the opposite.

@robverchick

Yeah except for the minor detail that Congress did not authorize the minting.

This is the problem with trying to subvert the democratic process.

@robverchick

It is up to Congress to authorize minting of money.

Really, all of these efforts to circumvent the democratic process are dangerous.

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.