Show newer

@failedLyndonLaRouchite

On the other hand, I think it's been amazingly notable over their years how lockstep the voting has been on the Democrat side, while the Republican side has seemed much more comfortable with diversity of thought.

I don't know what the lesson there is. Maybe don't judge books by covers? Maybe it's more about the people who elect the different parties? Maybe some sort of statistical averaging? Not sure.

But watching Democrats vote in lockstep this week has really driven that observation home.

@fkamiah17 @msmith1047 It's not only allowed, it's required by the rules.

The Rules of the House say that at this point in the process they are required to be in the process of voting every single moment that they are in session. They are required by the rules to continuously vote.

One way to think about it is that the next task in the queue is to vote for Speaker, so they have to do it unless they want to change the queue, but changing the queue requires a Speaker, sooooo...

They aren't voting over and over again because people want to. They're doing it because that is the required process.

US Politics 

@lilliassh

That would cause a lot of problems down the road because it would be a Speaker trying to manage votes of a chamber opposed to him. It would mean this gridlock on into the future.

But Democrats are free to vote present which would also end the gridlock in a way that has a speaker aligned with the majority.

@ZuriBella@toot.community

It isn't Dems helping Republicans pick someone.

It's breaking ties with fringe Republicans and choosing to oppose them, opening the House for business.

A few Democrats merely have to answer "present" and the fringe Republican impasse would collapse.

That's not helping anybody pick anybody. It's just getting out of the way of progress.

@kingsley

Because maybe the people that have been elected to serve in the House of Representatives might want to actually do that?

For a party supposedly full of problem solvers, it's pretty weird that the party is voting in lockstep to maintain the problem, taking the side of fringe Republicans to choose to keep the chamber from functioning.

@kingsley

I mean, the weird way that Democrats seem so eager to toe the line and conform is kind of something that a lot of us have been criticizing them for increasingly over the decades.

Yeah they stick together. Sometimes to an extent that just looks off-putting if not unhealthy.

@retrohondajunki @rbreich

I strongly disagree, as one would hope that Democrats would like to have an operational House in which the function.

Right now they are voting as a block to say they would rather have the House shut down, so they are already well into shenanigans.

They could be part of the solution. So far many Democrats have been explicitly saying they refuse to be.

@robert @Paulatics

Yes but keep in mind that it is intentionally the most representative chamber, representing an extremely divided country.

The population of the US is currently very chaotic so it only makes sense that the representatives of the people is in a similar state.

It's a reflection of the times we live in where people can't agree on the color of the sky.

@Paulatics Everything I've heard from Democrats has been really clear that they are voting as a block to keep the House shut down rather than accept Republican nominees.

So with them effectively siding with the fringe Republicans there's not really anywhere to go.

@matt

That's true, although we have to be careful about what the right moves are because certain improvements to Mastodon, making the right moves for Mastodon, amount to introducing proprietary elements that reflect the centralized platforms we're trying to get away from.

So we have to be a bit careful about what the right moves are.

@blepharon

Typo, sorry.

Unfortunately there's a lot of misinformation out there about the timeline of the US election and how it actually goes, so every once in awhile I get the urge to yell into the void to try to correct the record

@J3Words@mas.to

I appreciate that. It's just rough because there is so much misinformation out there, and so many people who do take things seriously even though they are being misled even by people who aren't joking.

These are difficult times.

@lindyli

He lost control a long time ago.

I sure wish people would stop treating him as if he was still particularly influential.

It only builds up his ego and keeps him annoyingly spouting off.

@J3Words@mas.to

To be clear, this isn't up to McCarthy.
The voting process is run by the clerk and responding to the entire body of representatives-elect.

McCarthy doesn't get to either make it continue or make it stop. It's up to the whole voting group to decide what to do.

volkris boosted

@philip_cardella

From listening to the holdouts giving interviews, in their own words, yeah that's pretty much my impression.

They don't seem to have a strong grasp of how the chamber operates, but then again, that seems to be the case with a whole lot of the people we elect and re-elect to do that job.

@philip_cardella

Even better: how many actually know how the House operates, what the Rules of the House are, what the committee structure is like, and how the Speaker engages with committee organizing and functioning?

In other words, regardless of how many care, how many actually know WHY they should care?

@fae

Sounds like the holdouts are receiving the brunt of blame.
McCarthy will likely be fine.

Heck, he'll get to rest on the supposedly great things he'll say he would have done, if not for those pesky rebels.

Show older
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.