While I had archived most of the important documents from Oceangate's website, I had forgotten to save Electroimpact's whitepaper in which they describe making the CF hull with their automated fiber placement machines.

In another source, Rush had said that it could not be cured all at once, so it had to cured in one inch layers.

Unfortunately, they didn't have a 5-inch thick CFRP barrel, they had 5 concentric 1 inch hulls with weaker bonds between them.

My hottest opinion is that I think CFRP submersibles could be made safe with better engineering.

@Lars I thought that CF was generally great under tension (like for COPVs), but not as good under compression. Is that correct?

@michaelgemar @Lars

The thesis paper concurs with your impression, Michael as I suspect other analysts do as well.

@michaelgemar @Lars
Better engineering as a remedy for what went wrong needs to be accompanied by better materials--the engineering analysts that have already gone before media cameras criticized the titanium-to-carbon adhesive used.

A couple of them also mentioned how glass-like carbon fiber gets under cold-with-high-pressure environments...and the thesis concurs with that analysis as well on page 11. She mentions adhesive creep in addition, tho I suspect that's at high temperatures and not lower temps when polymers of every sort tend to be more rigid, if not outright brittle too.

@ClaraListensprechen4 @Lars It really sounds like it’s a terrible material for this application, especially when other, far better characterized solutions are available and in regular use.

Follow

@michaelgemar @Lars

Still reading thru the thesis at this point...Chapter 3 is of particular interest in re: modeling stress test failure points, and I bring this part up because of a retired submarine Navy officer who opined that a big part of the problem wasn't the parts of uniform composite composition, but the fact that there were parts which were different from each other put together, and the junction of those disparate materials would have shown differences in stress response, thus extra-stressing the places they were joined.

In terms of simplistic application of pressure force, where one material has more give than the material it's joined to, the material with less give puts more stress on the part with more give to it. Even the best adhesives would give way under differential pressure, seems to me.

Especially when you have polymers that are more brittle because of the colder temperatures.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.