Follow

@saxnot No system is fully secured from polluting the surrounding area. Nothing is perfect, not even solar panels in that regard (lots of pollution created to make it).. What one needs to ask themselves is how the levels of pollution on average compare to others.

We already know there are types of reactors which are fundementally incapable of having a meltdown. So even if all the safety measures fail there is no more chance of the core melting down than a solar panel. The physics behind the choice of nuclear material makes it impossible.

So since we can garuntee at a fundemental level that melt downs wont happen (As we can) then what is the argument? If its just pollution due to proper disposal techniques then we would have to compare how the pollution compares to other methods.

I'm not even sure what your argument against nuclear is, like why would safety being imperfect even matter when meltdowns are possible?

@freemo @saxnot Well, what about solar plants that are just banks of mirrors tilted to focus ambient sunlight directly to a central tower to generate steam? I guess there's pollution in making the mirrors, and I have no idea what energy generation/efficiency looks like...

@freemo @saxnot and of course they tend to vaporize any birds unlucky enough to fly close to the central tower during the day/in the path of the beams

@savedr
There is at least some polution in the mirrors, negative enviromental impact from the occupied space, large impact on animals particularly birds (who often die as they fly past), etc.

I am not claiming it is worse or better than nuclear. Only that like any solution it is not free of consequences.

@saxnot

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.