@freemo

“‘When I use a word,’ Humpty Dumpty said in rather a scornful tone, ‘it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.’ ‘The question is,’ said Alice, ‘whether you can make words mean so many different things.’ ‘The question is,’ said Humpty Dumpty, ‘which is to be master — that's all.’” — Lewis Caroll, Through the Looking Glass

@billstclair
Yup one of m favorite quotes. Had it on the back of my mind when I was composing my response. Thanks for sharing glad I'm not the only one who thought of that.

@freemo

I always thought the point of that scene was to show what an idiot Humpty Dumpty is. Sorta makes me glad they couldn’t put the pieces together again.

@billstclair Sort of, the point is Are you a person with mastery of words (in which case the fact that they have many definitions play to your advantage) or do words have mastery over you (in which case the many definitions usually confuse and hold you back).

So the only person who would be an "idiot" in the context of that quote would be the person who cant find meaning in words due to their dynamic (many definitions) nature. So neither humpty nor Alice are idiots here really, but it does point to certain people you might describe that way.

Personally I find idiot to be too strong of a word, and just inflammatory. I'd likely not use it myself as it reeks of desperation and a desire to win an otherwise mature discussion.

@freemo

I’m an inflammatory sort of guy.

I love puns, but “libertarian” used to describe a political philosophy should have one meaning. The Libertarian Party, of course, is just a circle jerk for failed republicans.

@billstclair Libertarian party is a party, it does not define what is or is not libertarianism, that existed for much longer.

As much as it would be nice and clean if words had single definitions, they dont, least of all in politics. We see the same pattern of multiple definitions for other similar words such as conservative or even liberal (which has definitions unrelated to libertarian, though to some, particularly historically, they are interchangeable)

Sadly while your dogma may desperately want a single authoritative definition that conviently matches your own personal philosophy in reality that simply is not how language or words work.

@freemo

I do math and engineering. Words have precise meanings, and there are precise rules for combining those words. Get it wrong, and bridges collapse, airplanes fall from the sky, and people die.

The reason that political terms don't have precise meanings is so that those who would be king can have the rest of us arguing about things that were never said, because we're disagreeing with the other guys words using our meanings, not with what he actually said.

This is beneficial for the tyrants, because nobody notices that another French Revolution is way past due, where all of them would cease to exist. Violently.

If you refuse to agree on precise, agreed-upon meanings for the words we use, talking with you is a waste of my time.
Follow

@billstclair AS for me refusing to agree on precise definition. Sorry but neither I nor you get to dictate how language works. As much as both ofus might **like** and want definitions that is simply not reality.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.