A plea for those making WordPress sites for anyone other than themselves:

It's not OK to make each page hard-coded into a separate template.

Nowadays this seems paired directly to installing the Classic Editor plugin, but I'm tired of it on any site.

It is not good for anyone who has to interact with the site on the backend. Things are hidden, not searchable, and not editable. Content exists in a state that is invisible to most users, and inscrutable in how it is implemented. This mode of development hurts all users.

@david I need to find a plugin that just blocks me from visiting wordpress sites all together at this point.

:)

@freemo I imagine a browser extension would be created. With how porous it's gotten, integrating with other CMS' or becoming a headless CMS altogether, there may be some false negatives.

It would certainly make the web that you see smaller!

@david i wouldnt mind a few false negatives, doesnt need to be perfect.

Making the web smaller would be the whole point :) Selectively so. I personally hate wordpress with a passion

@freemo Considering how much of my personal and professional life revolves around it, I would be biased in discussion.

But I am curious as to the reasons that you have for that passion. I can think of several that I already agree with, but what about you?

@david ahh i didnt know you had a vested interest in wordpress. As such my apologies up front for what I'm about to say.

My hate is just expiernce, bloated, ugly, slow as hell compared to alternatives. To me it just feels like writing COBOL or something. Its old tech done in old ways and is ready to die, we have new and better ways to approach the vast majority of sites done with word press.

In the end, I just dont see it as quality software from the perspective of an admin who has tried to use it and as the perspective of a user who often accesses such sites. When they take 5 minutes to load and hang nine times out of ten when i look its wordpress.

Then there is also the fact that scammers so often use it to get a half decent looking site up quickly. Not the fault of word press but i have associated it with scammy sites so strongly that I'd be willing to block the whole thing from the internet just to avoid the scammy sites that use it.

I will admit my bias is strong and in many ways exaggerated and unfair to others. But it is my gut reaction all the same if im being honest.

@freemo Your reaction is valid nonetheless.

The push-back that I give is that it has made itself indispensable. That's not necessarily a good thing, for any tool or technology.

But there are a lot of people online, and a lot of people who get started with their place and knowledge of the web with WordPress. And with that level of accessibility it is, in my opinion, far greater than any of the negatives around it (of which I can personally think of many).

@david I cant argue that point a lot of people who needed to do a site but had no technical knowledge resorted to wordpress. Even I used it in the early days for my own blog.

Thing is those very people are usually part of the problem. I cant tell you how many non-tech friends have come to me and asked "hey my wordpress takes forever to load, can you help me fix it". Because of their lack of technical knowledge is probably a large part as to why wordpress got a bad name in the first place. Their lack of skill means a shitty website they cant diagnose and improve.

But in a way I think this also makes people lazy to learn. If people got started with other simple tools, lets say, static site generators, I think they would gain knowledge that would be more helpful to move them forward rather than stagnate, and actually wind up producing better quality sites in the long run.

@freemo I was thinking of static site generators when you suggested other tools. While they have been around for years (not even counting just static sites, around forever), they are now "the new hotness", based on interest and integration reaching more mainstream.

But I wanted to use that as a jumping off point. This is not intended to be confrontational, but what would you suggest someone use who wants to put together a nice looking business site but not be a developer?

@david If the business site is purely informational I'd still suggest a static site generator. If you use a preexisting theme (which is what anyone without expiernce would do even on wordpress) then all you need to know is markdown to fill it with content.

Now if they want something that is actually server-side because they want some functionality a static site generator cant easily provide, then in that case I'd say they should hire a developer or not attempt it :) If you cant afford it then perhaps a business that relies on custom tech isnt something you should be starting if you have no money and no tech expiernce :)

@freemo But does it rely on custom tech? All online setups have some drawbacks to them, but what is the non-technical person who wants to have an online presence do? They want to let people know that they have a storefront, here it is, here's the hours, here's what we sell.

WP isn't perfect, and I'm not defending it over static site generators in many cases. But is there one that does not require terminal knowledge to setup and maintain right now?

@freemo I shy away from the mindset that the web is just for specific people with certain knowledge, and I don't always think that knowledge needs to be grokked to have a presence when your focus is on running a business or doing something else more important than maintaining a website.

But I definitely don't want to push everyone into the hands of walled platforms that promise convenience in exchange for freedom.

Follow

@david Well i never said it was just for people with certain knwoledge. What i did say is that if you want to host your own server, that takes money from people and delivers goods you should have the expertise to do so effectively as you have a responsibility.

That doesnt mean you cant be on the internet, it just means you should use a service someone else hosts for you, like etsy.

If your going to handle money you have an obligation to be knowledge in the means in which you use to handle it, or defer to someone who is.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.