@adidasJack

Thats probably because those users blocked you and im about to block you as well if you keep tagging me.

If you arent trying to learn, dont tag me.

@a @CCoinTradingIdeas @TheRealSmij @Froghat

@adidasJack

Thank you. I'd be happy to try to explain but first what do you mean by "informational carrying medium", I assume that you mean "a medium which can carry information", what would make you think air can not carry information? Sound of course has information and it traves through air.

As for the "frequencies you are radiating" air is not really the medium that carries the waves in this case (though it may move through air) but rather space-time. This can be seen by the fact that we can transmit radio signals through a vacuum, so air is not a required component to transmission.

@CCoinTradingIdeas @TheRealSmij @Froghat

@adidasJack

Space is a field.

The issue is that you are trying to explain a fundemental object (a field) in terms of non-elementary objects.

Its a failing of human nature because those macroscopic things seem more real to us than the fundamental things. In reality it is the other way around.

All of space-time is a field and everthing we think of as objects are various types of perturbations in that field (waves).

So space-time is a field, it is the fundemental thing (not made up of things) and waves travel through it, which are little more than ripples in that field.

Are you a visual learner maybe? I can find some good educational videoa that can explain this to you graphically maybe it will help, there is also a talk with feynmann that is great... I will get them for you, please do watch them it will help answer your question

@CCoinTradingIdeas @TheRealSmij @Froghat

@freemo @adidasJack @CCoinTradingIdeas @TheRealSmij @Froghat When I began studying physics I had difficulty conceptualizing sub-atomic particles as "waves" and "balls" at the same time.
I tried to unify the concepts of ocean wave and soccer ball in many different ways, but it never made much sense. Is it a wave in a sea of balls? Is it waves in the surface of a ball?

It is neither!

The problem was that I was letting myself be guided by my everyday senses, touch and vision. But I had never seen or touched a sub-atomic particle.

Sometimes it's really hard to explain things in terms of others. I don't think I could explain a bed in terms of barks and cake smells.

So how did I do it?

I enhanced my senses. I enhanced my sense with experimentation. The double slit experiment tells us that sub-atomic particles have both, particle and wave properties, so I wrote a list of the properties of a particle in a piece of paper. The experiment and the list together form a new sense, the "empiricist sense". And it is as valid as vision or touch.

Now when I want to think of a soccer ball, I can use the information that my vision and touch senses provide me, that it is round and feels like sewed leather. Or I can use the information provided by the "empiricist sense" and think of it as a half baked electron.

The same thing goes with fields and fluids(or matter in general). Experimentation tells us that fields have certain properties and our everyday senses tell us that fluids have others. It can be really hard or impossible to make sense of fields in terms of fluids. So we use our new "empiricist sense" to see and feel the fields. Think of the field first and of the matter as a "half baked field" or just a crisp on it.

@the_daily_comfy

I always just thought of it as a wave that interacts at a point. If someone really needs a physical real world analogy the pilot wave model is compelling in that regard.

@adidasJack @CCoinTradingIdeas @Froghat @TheRealSmij

@adidasJack

Again ether is the wrong term. You really mean "field" not "ether", it isnt made up of a substance thus ether is not appropeiate

@the_daily_comfy @CCoinTradingIdeas @Froghat @TheRealSmij

@adidasJack

We can continue later if you wish.

But you have to understand what we mean when we say it isnt a substance and why we pick a different word, it has to do with the fact that it behaves differently.

If it were a substance than the speed of a wave through it would be relative to the substance it moves through. A wave in the ocean has a speed that is relative to the water. No matter how fast I am moving relative to that wave wont change this fact.

With space-time fields this is different, they are relative to the observer and not some medium

Think of the experiment which we used to disprove the Ether. Its like this, lets say i shoot a bullet at a target and it hits the bullseye. If the next time i shoot there is a cross-wind then the bullet wont hit its target anymore. The reason is because the bullet moves through a medium (air) and so if the air moves the bullet is carried along with that air.

But EM doesnt behave that way. If i shoot an EM wave at some target it will always travel in a straight line. If i shoot EM based gun at a target it doesnt matter how fast me and the target (in this case earth) is moving through space it always travels in a straight line. If it were moving through a substance then the EM field would "bend" as that substance flows.

@the_daily_comfy @CCoinTradingIdeas @Froghat @TheRealSmij

@freemo @adidasJack @the_daily_comfy @CCoinTradingIdeas @Froghat hoping not to be a reply guy, and I am not seeing the full convo. So maybe it’s irrelevant, but EM waves are bent, as in gravitational lensing, and their speed is affected by the medium they are traveling in, free space vs fiber optics for example. I know you know this, so are you just using simplifications for educational purposes?

@nonlinear

Gravitational lensing doesnt bend light, it bends the space time itself. Light still travels in a straight line.

But even that aside for a second (As that is a bit of a linguistic double-speak I admit) we arent talking about mass. We are talking about how the velocity of a spaceship shooting out lasers doesnt effect the speed or the direction at which lasers come out. Which would be effected if space-time were made of a substance like an ether, which it doesnt.

@Froghat @the_daily_comfy @CCoinTradingIdeas @adidasJack

@adidasJack

Those arent pictures of the path light takes. Thus the bending your seeing is also not a bending of light. Those are cathode ray tubes. The paths you see is the path **electrons** take not light. They simply cause the gas to glow as they pass through it and then the gas emmits light (which is traveling in a straight line to your eyes).

@nonlinear @Froghat @the_daily_comfy @CCoinTradingIdeas

Follow

@adidasJack

No that is not what I said.

The path of the green beam you are seeing is **not** the path of light. The freen color your seeing is light.

If i light a lighter the flame glows. I presume you are educated enough to know the lighter isnt just spewing light out of the top, flames arent **made** of light, they simply **emit** light. That is what you are seeing there, light is being emited but the beam that creates it (And thus being bent) is an electron beam, not a light beam.

Just think about it, when you turn on a flashlight in a clear house with no fog, you dont see the light beam itself, but you do see the spotlight on the wall. Moreover if you put a magnet near a flaashlight the light spot it makes on the wall wont move or bed from the magnet.

It should be immediately obvious why, now, what you are seeing in that picture is not a magnet bending light.

This is also why i say you have to learn the basic math before you try to say things. Did you solve that equation i gave you earlier and a few minutes ago?

@nonlinear @Froghat @the_daily_comfy @CCoinTradingIdeas

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.