florence fork's fantastic failure 

It's been a year since this post elekk.xyz/@maloki/101501797285504130 which was criticizing Mastodon and saying that "Fork Off" was going to actually be a project, after a lot of past hype and failed promises.

Since then, I think they've realized that actually, managing an open source project is difficult, and getting programmers to add the features you want is difficult. Their last pre-release (no releases at all) was in August 2019, still being based off of Mastodon 2.9.

Here is a list of all of the features they have added in the past year:
* configurable toot and biography lengths (copied from glitch social)
* users can get dm's on their home timeline if they choose to (copied from glitch social)
* more formal spanish translations

Of course, most of their commits are towards "improving" their code of conduct. Looks like they worked on it so much they didn't have any time for actual coding - I wonder why all the minority members who felt unwelcomed didn't show up, as promised?

You can have your "working groups" and discussions and meetings but at some point you need to actually do coding - having a team of community managers doesn't get you anywhere. At least Mastodon has managed to add features in the past year.

Although, thinking about it, the backlash that lead to this project was over Gargron adding a feature (trending hashtags) that people disagreed with - so maybe stagnation is the goal here.
Follow

re: florence fork's fantastic failure 

@mewmew The non-configurable and opinionated nature of mastodon is gargrons right. I also hate it about the project but im a coder so .. i... just... forked it...

That said it sounds like these people, as the post suggests, arent programers and as such they were pissed off by the fact that they had no say, they had to use it as is or not at all. I understand why they would be upset, it is a sort of dick move by gargron really, but again his choice.. But, it also means they will fail spectacularly at actually forking the project, since, their whole complain is that they dont know how to fork the project, oh the irony.

What they dont realize is if a project is going to succeed in almost all cases it means one highly driven guy doing 90%+ of the work and occasionally other people contribute back little snippets. Sounds like all they wanted to do was throw a temper tantrum and then expect the world to realize how amazingly enlightened they were and come together to contribute the code they cant do... sorry thats not how this stuff works.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.