When I was younger I was very pro-free-speech, then around age 20 or so I became woke. Then I got cancelled and it snapped me out of it. It turned my whole world upside down.

@alex

When I was younger I was very pro-free-speech, then around age 20 or so I became woke. Then I got cancelled and it snapped me out of it.

There’s no guarantee of free-speech in the US except from our government. (even that has restrictions) You aren’t guaranteed free speech on internet platforms, nor are you shielded from the effects of what you have said. Was there a certain statement that got you cancelled or was it a number of things?

@nothingplanet

Thats not exactly true, US law garuntees free speech everywhere, its just that people dont understand WHAT free speech means.

Free speech does not (and never did) mean that people are required to listen to you. Free speech has no meaning outside of law, it simply means that you will never be arrested for something you say, except int he case of a call to action for a crime. This is what free speech means.

Therefore, now that we made clear what free speech is it should be apparent why free speech extends to all spaces and places. No matter where you are or what platform you are on your freedom of speech (protection from arrest) is extended.

@alex

@freemo @alex Hello Dr Freemo. May I pose a question to you? If I start a small discussion forum online with open registration and you post messages I consider undesirable on it that I subsequently remove, have I violated your right to free speech?

@nothingplanet

No of course not, the only way you can violate someones freedom of speech is if you put them in jail for something they said. Short of that no ones freedom of speech is violated. You can, however, claim that the person was censored in a very specific way.

@alex

@freemo @alex OK. I think we are getting a little closer to understanding each other. I agree that censorship is when a person is prevented from saying what they want, whether it's by the government or other entities. However, I can't reconcile your earlier statement:

> it should be apparent why free speech extends to all spaces and places

You seemingly agree that in my example of a small website removing your posts that it is not a violation of free speech. I believe we both agree this IS censorship. Let me know if I am understanding you properly.

@nothingplanet

Yes thats correct we seem to be in agreement. A site that censors you does not violate your freedom of speech, but it is censorship.

@alex

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.