@rixx Well said.
Though there is a third option: ask the person politely to disengage. I find this works far better with none of the pitfalls usually.
I think most people reply to interact with the thread though not just the OP. So not sure they would feel their time is wasted.
I know if i find out ater im muted i dont feel as though my time is wasted. In fact it means i got to share my own opinions on the topic with those discussing it without the OP starting drama or getting in the way of civil discourse, so I think id see that as a win if it ever happened to me.