@freemo @stevenroose @igeljaeger @J

> the legal right to express one's opinions freely

If your going by that definition, what your saying makes sense.

Although, you could argue that hate speech can be considered opinion.

With calls to action/inciting violence, it could be considered your opinion that is what you want to do/done to them.

It would not cover lies though.

> No if you speak lied even when not under oath that would fall under slander

Not all lies are considered slander

> Oral communication of false and malicious statements that damage the reputation of another.

Only when it is malicious or it intends to cause damage.

@jasonl8446

Whether hatespeech is opinion really depends on how we are defining hate speech.

If you simply have a racist opinion, while we may agree that is unacceptable speech morally speaking, it isnt strictly speaking hate speech in my opinion.

To cross over into being hate speech there has to be some nature of "attacking" the person int he speech for it to be hateful. Despite the name I dont think "I hate you" is hate speech. but if you said "I hope you die" might be.

I think ther eis a fine but blurry line between a respectful opinion and explicit hate speech, even though there may be immoralities on either side of that line.

If it is your opinion that peope should start a riot, that is not a call to action, so no.. You would have to say 'Everyone here, lets riot!" then you are expressing a call to actiont hat goes beyond a simple opinion. So yes these are strongly different.

As for not all lies being slander, that part I agree with. To qualify as slander the person saying the lie needs to know it is a lie at the time they say it, or there needs to be reasonable evidence to suggest the person most likely knew it was a lie. Now to actually be legally actionable you have to actually hurt someone with that lie, or else there is nothing to actually sue for. But either way it is not protected speech.

@J@gameliberty.club @igeljaeger @stevenroose

@freemo @J @igeljaeger @stevenroose

Hate speech is a difficult topic, I honestly do not completely understand it myself, no point in putting empty arguments about something I am ignorant about.

> If it is your opinion that peope should start a riot, that is not a call to action, so no.. You would have to say 'Everyone here, lets riot!" then you are expressing a call to actiont hat goes beyond a simple opinion. So yes these are strongly different.

Yeah, I guess that is true

> To qualify as slander the person saying the lie needs to know it is a lie at the time they say it, or there needs to be reasonable evidence to suggest the person most likely knew it was a lie

That is true, and it needs to contain malicious intent. Not all lies have malicious intent.
Follow

@jasonl8446

Well the malicious intent part isnt untrue, but its more of a consequence of the mechanics of it than inherent to what slander is. In order for there to be civil legal action (the domain slander operates in) then there needs to be someone who was financially damaged by it. It isnt that there needs to be malicious intent, only that the result must be damaging in order to be actionable as a civil suit (otherwise who are you even going to sue?).

I think this becomes evident if we look at the definition of slander from a law dictionary specifically in which case we can see a similar but more appropriate definition in line with what I said:

Oral defamation, in which someone tells one or more persons an untruth about another, which untruth will harm the reputation of the person defamed.

@J@gameliberty.club @igeljaeger @stevenroose

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.