@mntmn That looks like a lot of wasted space.. but I guess thats hard to get around if your gonna use tube shaped batteries.
@freemo you see wasted space, i see space to comfortably work with
@mntmn really? how would you effectively fill up the space around each battery cell. That seems like a small space and filling it would make it hard to remove the battery.
I'd be curious to your ideas there.
@mntmn get that. But the problem with taking os space in a cylindrical fashion like that is its hard to make the extrac space useful (with custom modules and such). Thats just a sad fact of dealing with space fitting circles which are the least efficient space filling shape.
The same size battery but in a flat shape would leave the same amount of area but in a congruent shape with flat sides that is much easier to work with (for additional modules and such as you say).
Don't get me wrong, it is nice your using easier to obtain batteries I guess. But there are standard flat cells too that would likely work better all around is all im saying (and lighter too).
@mntmn Well im sure you know of the standard connectors already no? Past that the specific size doesnt need to be standardized. Just have a nice large space and any battery of the appropriate voltage that fits in there works
We are talking a rectangular space so just provide a space and any pouch as big or smaller can go in. The connector is the only part youd really have to standardize I'd think.
@freemo which standard connector do you mean on LiFePO4 pouch cells? i've only seen screw/solder tabs. where will end users by these pouch cells?
@mntmn Well the specific conenctor you would choose would depend if you want to ba able to have a line going to each cell or not, I dont know what powermanagement circuit your going with. Literally any standard connector with enough lines on it would work, there are countless.
As for where they would get the pouch, since they would only need to match the correct number of cells (and thus voltage) they could literally buy from anywhere, such as e-bay, amazing, hell they can take one out of an existing device if they want. thats the beauty of it, a little bigger a little smaller, doesnt even matter as long as it fits and you have the right number of cells.
@freemo you can see the battery management circuit on page three here http://dump.mntmn.com/reform2-allinone-a3.pdf
Please link me to the exact connectors and sources of the flat LiFePO4 battery cells that you think people should buy. So far you haven't backed up your criticism with any concrete standard connector or easily accessible source of battery (and please make sure it is the correct chemistry).
@mntmn Well I obviously cant tell you specifics without knowing a little more, specifically the max current youd draw from the batteries.
If I had to guess you could go with a moplex pico-clasp or picoblade connector. either two seperate connectors of 5 each or a single connector of 10 pins.
As I said for the battery itself there is no neeed to go with a single specific brand, the beauty would be that any brand from anywhere can be used with the right chemistry. Some examples of such batteries from three seperate vendors below, but like i said the user can literally pick any vendor or brand they want.
Personally I would even go a step further and ensure the charging circuit works for other common chemistires so a user can even pick other chemistries if they wish. Then I'd make the space big enough so you can pop in an adapter if you really want to use cylinder shapped batteries, or keep the adapter out and use the pouch batteries and get the extra space for the same power. All up to what you throw in.
I see no reason to really lock into a specific batter size especially giving how ineffective it is on managing space.
https://www.electriccarpartscompany.com/Bestgo-20Ah-LiFePO4-Lithium-Pouch-Cell
https://www.bestgobattery.com/pouch-cells/lifepo4-cells.html
@freemo ok, but the batteries are already on modular PCBs and they already connect to the motherboards using molex picolock connectors (groups of 4 cells each), so you could just do that modification you want, actually. we had these pouch cells in Reform 1, i'm very familiar with them, and we dropped them because there are no standard sizes and they are not trivial to connect. you have to use point welding or stamp holes and screw to a terminal. you also would need custom fixtures for them.
@freemo have you even looked at how Reform is structured?
@mntmn Not in extream detail. I've followed the photos, I have a high level picture at best. I have not done a deep dive.
I am an EE so was just trying to give some advice but you clarified that in your last post.
@mntmn Ok fair points. In fact if the connector is there, and the holder for the batteries can come out completely, then i'd say your already where I would have wanted to see things go. So sounds like we have the same line of thinking based on what you just said :) I am a fan then.
Hate to be a aprty poop.. i was about to hit the buy button and noticed it was only 1080P resolution... I can barely function these days without a 4K HD
What are the chance there will be an upgrade option to 4K HD at some point. If thats an option I'll buy that when it becomes available.
Well honestly i only ever buy 15" laptops either.. not trying to give you a hard time, please. Maybe that will be a later model, I love what your doing its epic.
But yea for me my only requirements for a laptop usually is
*15" or bigger,
*4K UHD or higher
* compatible with linux
I guess I'll just have to wait for a later model to get in (I didnt notice the screen size when I spoke).. but if you ever get to those specs I will pay whatever it costs to get one :)
@freemo which standards are there for flat LiFePO4 cells? i only know of randomly sized pouch cells offered by some chinese sellers