For someone who claims to be a free speech extremist and encourage hellthreads, @p sure does ban a lot of people for practicing free speech.
@Ricotta I plan to ban a shithead for spamming repeatedly, and doing nothing but spamming. I haven't heard anything in his defense yet. You got anything?
@p So now it's only free speech when you approve of it? :cirnoThink:
@Ricotta Plenty of shit I don't approve of is fine to post. It's the constant stream of spam that he crams into every thread. That was the reason for the first ban on FSE; nothing has changed there. Here is the most recent example:
nobody_pending_ban.png
@p But the child grooming victim who shits up every thread he sees and spams you with 500 notifications a day is fine?
@Ricotta Huge difference between a kid and a guy that knows exactly what he's doing and is an intentional dickhead.
@p One set of standards for one group and another set of standards for another is not free speech extremism. It's basically exactly what Twitter has been doing, and why so many of us are on the Fediverse in the first place.

I'm not saying that moderation shouldn't be done, but given that you're a self-proclaimed champion of free speech, I expect you to hold yourself to a higher standard. Selective moderation is not meeting that standard.

At the end of the day it's your instance and you can do whatever you want, but I really expect better from you.
@Ricotta

> One set of standards for one group and another set of standards for another

If your complaint is specifically about Jojo, you should know the difference between accidentally stepping on someone else's toes and stomping on them intentionally, and Jojo *did* get banned for a while. If there's some other group you mean, let me know.

> Selective moderation

Spam has always been against the rules. It's not content-based. You should know that already. The @protestation account got banned, for example, for violating the bot rules. There are rules, that's it.
@p
>If your complaint is specifically about Jojo, you should know the difference between accidentally stepping on someone else's toes and stomping on them intentionally,
Yet you refuse to enforce this against him:
>We will take down anything that gets us into legal trouble. Repeat offenders get the banhammer (after ample warning).
Surely his using your platform to try to hook up with adult men would more than qualify as something that would get you into legal trouble. Especially since he admitted to sending child pornography that he produced to at least one of those men. Regardless of whether the CP was transmitted via your instance, that's a massive legal liability.

>Spam has always been against the rules. It's not content-based.
It is, however, incredibly subjective. And considering that you condone and in fact encourage hellthreads, which anyone not interested in participating in them would likely consider spam as well, I'd argue that you haven't got a leg to stand on as far as banning someone for spam while maintaining your integrity as a free speech extremist.
@Ricotta

> Regardless of whether the CP was transmitted via your instance,

If it didn't touch my server, then I don't give a damn about it. He's on NB now anyway, yell at sjw if this is a legitimate concern to you. I am coding right now and I don't give a damn about drama when I'm *not* busy.

> It is, however, incredibly subjective.

If anyone has any problems understanding the definition in the rules, I'll answer questions at length. I have answered questions for @Nobody over and over and over again, and he pretends to understand when I'm waving a banhammer around and then suddenly forgets.

I want to point out one thing, as we have actually had a lawyer look into the question of spam ont he fediverse before in an attempt to define our own internal moderation rules at QOTO.

The key to spam in the setting of the fediverse is if people are allowed to opt-out or not.

That means if someone has explicitly asked to not be included in a person or group of peoples messages (such as a hell thread) and they are continually included anyway, then this would count as a violation of the CAN-SPAM act and thus illegal within the USA.

However simply be included in a hell thread, or being included by someone who is not aware of your desire to opt-out would not be considered spam.

Keep in mind this is slightly different than how the law around email would be treated where spam is illegal if you havent explicitly opted-in. The reason for this, as it was explained to me, is because the nature of the fediverse implies you are open to being contacted by random people and groups as a matter of discourse. So while you retain the right to opt-out you do not have to explicitly opt-in.

With all that said I have found the hell threads produced by P's server in my case to generally follow these rules. When I first got included in hell threads I made the mistake of thinking it was intended as an attack, I complained and P ensured he let the group know not to include me and I was not. Once I realized they were just people joking around and having fun, and not intended as an attack I didnt mind and have since participated in them. Either way I'd say even though I'm not a lawyer it would appear P's server is in compliance with the CAN-SPAM act as it was described to me by our lawyer.

@p @Nobody@freespeechextremist.com @Lainyboy @Ricotta

@freemo @p @Nobody
Interesting. :cirnoThink:

>However simply be included in a hell thread, or being included by someone who is not aware of your desire to opt-out would not be considered spam.
And when it's the same group of users consistently tagging users who have previously requested to not be involved in hellthreads into new hellthreads?
Follow

@Ricotta

Then as far as I understand it that would be illegal ad a violation of CAN-SPAM act law.

If you have sufficiently demonstrated that to P and he has allowed those users to continue to operate on his server then as far as I understand it P and his server would be in violation of the law.

With that said I am only reiteriting what our lawyer told me to the best of my knowledge. So take it with a grain of salt.

@Nobody@freespeechextremist.com @p

@freemo @Ricotta @Nobody Another county heard from!

> Then as far as I understand it that would be illegal ad a violation of CAN-SPAM act law.

No, that's stupid, and I don't care what your lawyer says about CAN-SPAM unless he'll send me a sworn affidavit that he believes this to be the case and that he intends to file an amicus curiae should I run into a related matter and request it.

@p

Get off your high horse. I came in and tried to defend you. Dont blame me your users are going around harsssing and spaming users.

I am telling you what I learned do with it what you will. No I wont spend the money on my lawyer to write you a signed affidavid.

If you dont care if your users harass others explicitly after being asked not to send content to their account, I frankly dont give a shit. You are only screwing yourself over.

Personally every tie i try to defend it or your server I regret it anyway at this point.

@Nobody@freespeechextremist.com @Ricotta

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.