@DaveTLV yeah we just pay people to forcibly impregnate cows and kill the babbys for that delicious grief milk. bears should get currency.
@DaveTLV no but I think that's a little weird if other meats are.
@Ox It's not kosher specifically because traditionally raised veal is raised in a way considered cruel by Jewish law.
@Ox While the main intent of Kashrut laws are public health related, one of the things about it is that an animal cannot be treated cruelly. It is considered a cruelty to separate a calf from it's mother and basically cage it or chain it up so it can't develop properly and stay "tender"/
@DaveTLV I would consider killing any animal unnecessarily to be cruel.
@Ox I think I can agree with that statement. I suppose the real question is, though, what does "Unnecessary" mean in this context.
@DaveTLV there is no other food source available or the animals quality of life is such that it's suffering and should be put at rest humanely
@Ox I would disagree on that. While I do believe that we've perhaps gone a bit overboard on meat production and consumption the truth is we evolved to eat at least some animal protean. The ability to completely cut meat out of the diet is a very modern invention- and I mean less than 100 years style modern.

Only the global market, with it's ability to draw produce from many different growing regions allows the nutritional balance required to eat healthfully. And, that's really only in countries where such a global economy has really taken route. Even then, there are areas that are less developed and require more local agriculture to feed their people.

Eating healthfully within that global market can also be quite expensive- far more than some of the less fortunate within even first world nations can afford.

There is truth, however, in how we treat animals being a reflection of our humanity. This should absolutely extend to how we treat and raise livestock. There should be no suffering for those we will be eating and when it comes time to slaughter the animal it should be done in the most humane, painless, and quick way possible.
@DaveTLV it is modern. and eventually I hope everyone will get there.
Follow

@Ox

Sadly we would have a very hard time converting to veganism entierly and still sustaining the population. But for what its worth I too would like to see a greater shift in that direction at least.

@DaveTLV

@freemo @DaveTLV I have hopes it can happen in the future. we don't know what technological and world advances will be made. nothing will change my views on this. they're cemented in my ethics.

@Ox

I hope your right, but I dont think it is likely short of cutting the world population down. Which admittedly would be a smart move.

@DaveTLV

@freemo @Ox It would be ethically ideal if we did not have to kill animals to survive. I, too, hope that in the future we can move towards that sort of society and lifestyle.
@freemo @Ox And I'm not trying to change your views, Oxie. They're part of who you are and I love ya for who you are.
@DaveTLV @freemo thanks Dave. I just have strong opinions and feelings on the topic.
@Ox @freemo Which is okay! I just find it interesting that even in the bronze age this was on people's minds to some degree.

@DaveTLV

Many kosher laws make a lot of sense even outside of the welfare of the animal.. just in terms of our own food safety too... Its an early day version of the FDA in a weird way :)

@Ox

@freemo @Ox Yes. There is still a lot of argument within some circles if the laws came up due to cultural, health, or some other reasons- but the benefit is absolutely health related.

Due to the whole 'An animal has to be clean' it means that the animals needed to be kept healthy, they needed to be kept humanely, and they needed to be kept in a clean environment where they weren't being abused.

I can't say if the original intent was to give the Proto-Jewish people of the time a cultural connection through food, or if it was health related or anything else, to be honest. I don't think it's something we know, and due to the nature of culture shift I'm not sure it's something we can know unless some bit of archaeological evidence pops up that specifically lets us know about it.

As far as religiously held dietary laws go, I feel kashrut is mostly benign.

@DaveTLV

The thing is, we see this sort of pattern of religious practices ultimately lining up with legitimate health concerns in almost all religions. So it makes a lot of sense that it evolved, unintentionally to that purpose and they just thought it was god giving them a sign.

When people ate meat that was on the verge of death when it was killed they got sick and diedd themselves. When people ate healthier meat they lives. Overtime superstition arose that it was just god wanting people to do this or that, and it largely reflected the health, though that was never an intentional decision. It happened naturally as the consequence of their superstition.

We see the same in christian religions. For example people quickly noticed that people who drank beer were healthier than people who drank water. This was thought to be some magical gift imparted on beer by god. This is why the Catholics have saints specifically associated with beer and why it was routine for most churches to brew their own beer as part of a monk's duties, which they viewed as sacred. Even today many ales have long traditions and still brewed by monks (like trappist ales).

In reality it was just because the boiling process associated with making beer killed off many of the germs so fewer people died from it.

@Ox

@freemo @DaveTLV I'm hopeful with greater access to medical care and reproductive healthcare that our population will eventually be decreasing until we reach a sustainable level. obviously, it will take many lifetimes. but I act with the intention of consequences to succeed my own lifespan.
Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.