@hansw the simple fact remains, the Dutch virtually never use a face mask and have virtually eliminated COVID at this point. QED

@happymoomoo @freemo @Galena Honestly, a lot of people here just don't care. They basically break all the guidelines. Telling them to wear a mask won't make them stop following other guidelines, because they don't follow them anyway. How you get people like that to wear a mask, I don't know...
@sim Many of us refuse to put on the mask because we know better. @Galena @freemo
@happymoomoo @Galena @freemo Is not keeping your distance another thing where you know better though?
@sim If all the blm+antifa "peaceful" "protesting" over the past 51 (52? 54?) days straight isn't enough to convince someone that social distancing is total bull, I can't imagine what will. @Galena @freemo
@happymoomoo @Galena @freemo Why is that total bull? Sounds more like there has been political spin to make it out to be not as bad. I still remember people going on holiday abroad, catching it and spreading it back home. Or that there were new cases at nightclubs or even the case with a choir.

@sim

To be fair right after the protests we saw a pretty huge spike in COVID numbers.. if anything it was able to prove social distancing is **not** bull.

Masks arent bull either, they serve a purpose in some very specific situations and when handled properly. It is just when used by the general public all teh time they become more of a vector for disease than a benefit.

@happymoomoo @Galena

@freemo @sim @happymoomoo @Galena The research I read said that the protestors didn't get sick and if I'm to bring my own anecdotal evidence, it's true even here in Arizona where the problem is exceptionally bad. My understanding is the risk of transmission outdoors is just not very high
Follow

@penny

We dont have good data to say one way or the other if transmission is signficiant outdoors compared to in, its mostly speculation.

As far as speculation goes though you will notice a pretty big 180 that happened right around the protests. Prior to the protests we were under full lock down to the extent the official advice was that even if you keep 6 foot distance you shouldnt even be gathering in groups outisde. Claiming the only thing people should be doing is their essentials and coming righthome. then all of a sudden you have protests and people are looking for ways to justify it and people change their tune.

Moreover if you look more closely at the examples we have we know that transmission outdoors is, in fact, pretty significant. For example Iceland did one of the most extensive genomic studies of the virus we have testing hugs numbers of people and actually sequencing the genes on these people. Through this they were able to track how the virus skipped hosts through its transmission. they found an outdoor sporting event was in fact the biggest route of transmission and caused the largest jump int he infection they saw. This paints a pretty clear picture that events like protests are going to be a huge vector despite what people may be saying.

@happymoomoo @Galena @sim

@freemo @happymoomoo @Galena @sim the researchers specifically tested the protesters though, they simply weren't the ones who got sick. Scientist believe the protesters did help cause this spike not by spreading the disease themselves but by the social ramifications
@freemo @Galena @happymoomoo @sim instead of getting sick themselves, it just massively encouraged infractions, which means parties and in Arizona, bars

@penny

Lets see the source, because otherwise this claim sounds highlys uspect and we have counter examples against it anyway.

I suspect it has more to do with their young age and therefore being asymptomatic and thus not tested as much, which is why I want to check the study, make sure the testing was truly random and age controlled.

@sim @Galena @happymoomoo

@penny

I am more than happy to see any study you have that compares the rate of infection among protestors to the rate of infection among the general population of the same age. But that sounds highly suspect without a good **peer-reviewed** source

@happymoomoo @Galena @sim

@penny

Notice the paper you just shared is a "working series", as in, it is a preliminary draft, not a final, and more importantly is not peer-reviewed.

So the argument you made earlier that "everyone agrees" wouldnt not be demonstrated by this paper since it is, at this point, little more than one mans opinion. with that said, I will give the paper a full read all the same. But I'm pretty skeptical going in considering what I just pointed out.

@happymoomoo @Galena @sim

@freemo @happymoomoo @Galena @sim right I wasn't basing my life off just that, it's just another piece of the puzzle, one that fits my anecdotal experience because most of us have gotten tested since the protest ourselves that's so far me and my friends and compatriots have all come back clean

@penny

Thats the problem with anecdotal evidence... Lets be clear here, less than 1% of the population has COVID. Even if you are a HUGE risk at spreading the disease in a protest setting afterwards your still only going to have a small percentage infected. If 5% of protestors were infected that a 5x increase over background and would show a huge infection rate. But even at 5% infection you and all your friends can go get tested and your still likely to come up negative.

Your entire stance is based off very weak evidence and I suspect is more personal bias than objective fact to be honest.

@happymoomoo @Galena @sim

@freemo @happymoomoo @Galena @sim (conversely I had one "friend" who threw a party indoors and you can guess how that story ends)

@penny

4.4% is the percentage of people over **all time** who had been given a positive test result. That would include people who months ago tested positive and since recovered. The number of people currently infected is much much smaller and likely still under 1% (though i dont know the exact number).

@happymoomoo @Galena @sim

@penny @freemo @Galena @happymoomoo @sim the researchers did not test the protesters. Scientists do not believe that the virus was spread through "social ramifications".

Why do you say this? the media didn't give a shit about the people dying in China in October and November from covid, how come they care so much come February?
@freemo @penny @happymoomoo @Galena Interestingly though, don't many of the protestors wear a face covering or mask? I wonder how that has helped them.
Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.