Yes and I addressed that already, I shouldnt need to repeat myself.. are YOU reading the responses?
As I stated earlier what people are allowed to do or wht the law is is fairly irrelevant to the case I'm making. I am talking about if people actually wear them, regardless of if they are allowed to do so or not. Furthermore your personal experience as to if they actually wear a mask or not is welcome, but as i already said hardly tells us if that is common place across other places in europe as well.
So yes, providing webcams is a better line of evidence than your own personal anecdotal evidence.
Do I call that science, no.. but I never claimed it to be science. I did claim it to be reasoning logically however and drawing conclusions based on what limited evidence i have at my disposal, even if the evidence is not sufficient to qualify as science on its own.
I will say this, in the paper I am writing I do intend to correlate mask laws to the spread of COVId under a granger causality test, and do have much of the raw data for that. But that isnt really going to be helpful in this conversations as it is little more than tables of numbers right now.
Lets look at the WHO document on page 6 after the qoute @freemo made
"However, taking into account ......., a growing compendium of observational evidence on the use of masks by the general public in several countries ........, WHO has updated its guidance to advise that to prevent COVID-19 transmission effectively in areas of community transmission, governments should encourage the general public to wear masks in specific situations and settings ...."
Yes I covered that language in post.
"First lets look at the WHO which does not recommend people wear masks except under certain situations"
this is what I said in the OP. Notice a very clearly and directly state "except under certain situations".. this is directly in line with the part you just quoted where it says "wear masks in specific situations"
My argument is not that you should never wear masks under any circumstance. I made the argument we should not wears masks all the time when in public, which is exactly what the who states and the quote you just provided agrees with that statement.
@freemo
These certain situations are in the row 1 to 3 of the table. And exact these are the things which are mandatory and used here in Germany with success.
You should also take into account that countries are in different phases of spreading. For example Austria is about two/three weeks ahead of Germany, so action about corona are not syncronized in different European countries.
@mf Great, I'm glad you use masks in highly infectious zones where social distancing is not possible. You'r point? My argument was against people wearing masks "all the time".. if you wear a mask when caring for an infected relative or when entering a highly infected zone where you cant keep physical distance, then great! Just be sure to only use it for short periods of time and throw it away immediately after use.
Generally, as the paper points out, enforcing social distancing inside grocery stores, however, is preferred over masks. So as the WHO states as long as you can keep that 2 meter distance as you go down aisles then the mask isnt needed. If for some reason your entering a store where that isnt the case a mask is simply your only choice.
@mf The stores in the netherlands dont require masks because all they do is put 2M markers on the ground. If you get closer than 2 meters to someone you will be reprimanded.
It is quite easy to maintain 2m distance in a store IF everyone is complying with the rule. If there are too many people in the store at the time for more to enter and remain distanced, you form a line outside. Problem solved.
So yea you shouldnt need masks in stores. but if you need to go into a store where the owner is irresponsible and doesnt enforce social distancing, wear a mask if you have no other reprieve.
@mf Oh and regard to 6 weeks being kinda old.. The WHO publishes new guidelines any time they feel an old one is out of date. They have not provided any updated guidelines that change anything in this conversation. It is still the active guidelines as of today.