Follow

@hansw I certainly understand your concern regarding opt-out/opt-in.. the issue is that the servers dont really give individuals the power to opt in or out, its at the server level. Ideally users should be able to opt-out and the server would update the robots.txt or metatags to reflect the fact that you opted out of search indexing.

The issue with user-level control over opting out seems to be a lack of a feature in mastodon and in and of itself not an issue with fedisearch, whom are doing their best to comply with the standards that do exist with handling that. The issue is we either need better standards or software which works with those standards better.

Keep in mind, however, google is already indexing what you post, as is every other search engine on this planet, and they are all following the same rules as @fedisearch is. So while I do consider your concerns valid, I'm not sure its so much an ethical issue from fedisearch as it is a standards issue.

As for your analogy for spam, that seems to be largely unrelated. Opting into someone sending you advertisements seems like a very different situation that opting into your publicly hosting content being indexed. This isnt to say that your concerns are any less valid, they arent, but just saying im not sure spam is a good analogy to call on.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.