I, a white man, have written the first draft of a blog post on a topic related to racism. It’s about the idea of “white culture” (not an actual thing) and white people’s relationship to culture (also not really a thing) and the place that fixing that problem has in the anti-racism work of white people.

I’m wondering if anyone on here might do me the favor of giving me feedback about it before I publish it. If so, let me know and I’ll send you a link.

@benhamill I would be happy to,but to figure out if I will be bias out of the gate from your perspective or not let me ask one qualifying question.

If you do not believe white culture is a thing (presumably because white is spread across the globe and not a singular culture)... I presume you would also think black culture isnt a thing for the same reason?

@freemo I don’t feel _super_ qualified to answer that because I am not Black, but I’ll put a finer point on it and say that white US culture isn’t a thing. It’s not about internationality so much as it is an erasure by smooshing preexisting cultures together in order to forge a unified whiteness. And white people have been unable to create a culture in the US that is in any way distinguishable from white supremacy culture.

@freemo Whereas Black people, I would argue, have been able to create a true culture in the US. With, of course, regional variations and all that. But an institution that stands in its own and is often part of the defensive mechanism against racism.

They are not the only people that have done a similar thing, but probably the one that had to do the largest amount of cultural construction from scratch.

@benhamill Ahh so you are talking exclusively of blacks and whites in the US and dont feel this applies to blacks and whites in other parts of the world, whom you admit may have a culture or may not (I live mostly in the netherlands these days but also live in the USA at times)?

@freemo I would say, perhaps, “mainly” rather than “exclusively”, but yeah. Having only lived in the US, I can’t say what’s up in other countries with much authority.

But my thinking would expect that the culture in the Netherlands would not be white culture, but _Dutch_ culture. If that distinction makes sense to you? It’s is not a culture of whiteness, but a culture of Dutchness (which Black people or other people of color may partake).

@freemo This makes me think I may need to be sure to talk a little about what I mean by “culture”. It’s vague enough that I probably can’t do a real definition, but it might help. IDK.

@benhamill
Generally my expiernce in Europe is there are many levels of culture. I live near Utrecht, a region and city in the Netherlands.

There is a regional culture and pride in the Utrecht area (or sometimes even your small town).. There is a seperate culture for the Dutch as a whole, and there is another culture that europeans share as a whole, this last one is often interchangeable with "white culture", at least how americans tend to use it (since whites displaced from europe may see their european ties as the culture they took with them).

So at least in europe there is a very distinct white culture but it is not the only identity/culture.

Now here is the catch, and why I put "white culture" in quotes.. In europe the color of your skin and even your heritage and race is not really how people identify.. A black person living in the netherlands if asked "what is your culture" will not say "I am black".. they would say something more like "I am a 2nd generation Dutch immigrant who migrated here from Etheopia".. The color of ones skin isnt really a category of any consequence, such an immigrant would be seen as part of European Culture and not exclusive to it.

In other words the mentality in europe is that culture is not an exclusive club you can get into (or not) by the color of your skin but rather by the environment you choose to be a part of.

@benhamill

Anyway, now that I've heard your perspective if you'd like I'd be happy to give you mine on the US interpretation of white/black culture (I am mixed race myself so straddle the line between minority and white).

I'd also be happy to read your draft and give direct feedback if youd like.

@freemo Sure. Please share. I'm about to step away from the computer for the night, so it will probably be Quite Some Time™ before I can spend real time reading it, though. Be forewarned.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.