I've never heard of a heavily communist or socialist society with a booming economy.

@realcaseyrollins How would you measure a "booming economy" in the context of a communism anyway? Usually we rate the health of an economy by how much disposable income someone has. The whole point of a communism is that there is no distinction between disposable income since there is no code income needed for necessities, those are (supposedly) provided.

@freemo That's a good question.

Cumulative wealth divided by the population and compared to median wealth? GDP? Growth of businesses?

I don't think disposable income should be the best indicator of a good economy, but rather the economy's ability to perform, grow and expand.

@realcaseyrollins

In that case here you go, a graph of previously communist countries showing GDP per capita. You can clearly see how the growth of GDP changed pre and post communism here as well as the cost of the transition itself.

@freemo I wonder why nobody goes "oh wow, look at that Bulgarian economy" haha
@freemo Maybe they're looking at the wrong indicators? People praised the 2019-2020 #Trump economy but IMHO, especially during #COVID, it was artificially propped up by stimmys

@realcaseyrollins Perhaps, this is largely why I asked you what the indicators should be and then provided whatever that was.

@freemo I do generally stand by my initial opinion that communism and socialism don't scale well in larger countries.

Healthcare in tiny socialist countries can be impressive though, from what I've heard

@realcaseyrollins I am of the opinion that communism generally fails both economically and in terms of personal freedoms.

In the charts I provided you can clearly see that the rate of increase int he GDP is significantly higher post-communism than pre-communism for most of those countries.

@freemo clearly? The GDP in both scenarios seems largely similar, with apparently some more stability under communism.
Follow

@realcaseyrollins You are looking at the GDP, thats the wrong thing, you need to look at the rate of change of the GDP, the slow of the lines not their position.

@freemo No that's what I mean, the slopes are largely similar in most scenarios

@realcaseyrollins on second look perhaps its less obvious than I first thought. One would have to calculate the actual slopws here to really say I suppose. It also isnt the best graph considering it is cut off a bit too early anyway.

@freemo True. It seems more consistent though, for what I can see
Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.