"Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen said Thursday that China would be among the first in line to get paid under a Republican proposal to prioritize some U.S. debt obligations over others, calling it a “dangerous idea” that would technically cause the U.S. to default on its bonds."

#DebtCeiling #Congress #Republicans

cnbc.com/2023/03/16/debt-ceili

@marynelson8

The problem is this is an executive branch function, not a legislative branch function. This misses the separation of powers of the US federal government.

@volkris Those who oppose raising the debt ceiling don't actually understand what they're doing. These "remedies" won't solve the problem. Holding the debt ceiling hostage for political gain uses the full faith and credit of our government (and country) as a bargaining chip, without considering the implications or the disaster they're courting. The impact of default could be devastating.

@marynelson8

Except that's not how the federal government works.

The full faith and credit are executive branch functions, not legislative branch. The legislative branch has no control over the executive branch paying its debt obligations.

I know a lot of places are reporting as if it is, but they are misreporting issues of basic civics, basic functions of the federal government.

The executive branch has to pay its obligations. It doesn't matter what Congress does, the executive branch must pay the debts as they come due. They have enough money to do so, so they constitutionally must do so.

If the president decides not to pay his obligations, that would be an impeachable offense.

@volkris The executive has to follow the law. That one of its basic charges. Therefore it must not exceed the debt limit, a law Congress was responsible for passing.

I understand your point but it's a matter of the necessity of Congress lifting the ceiling it set by law.

Follow

@marynelson8

No the executive has to follow LEGAL law.

The legislature is not free to write just whatever law it wants. The legislature is not free to violate the separation of powers inherent in the structure of the US government. It is not legal for the legislature to pass unconstitutional laws.

This is fundamental to the design of the US government, and for a very very good reasons.

And so the executive is legally, constitutionally, required to pay the debts of the United States regardless of what the legislative branch may say.

@volkris As the Congressional Research Service has said, "Congress has always limited debt." It began in 1917, when the Second Liberty Bond Act of 1917 was enacted. Congress has, and always has had, the power of the purse to decide how much the U.S. Government can spend. That includes what the Executive Branch can spend. Thus it must be the branch of government to lift the ceiling originally set in the law.

History links:
CRS:
crsreports.congress.gov/produc

Explainer from NPR:
npr.org/2023/01/21/1150078028/

@marynelson8

It's even more fundamental than that, going back to the 1780s.

The Constitution assigns to Congress the authority "To borrow Money on the credit of the United States;"

But since the authority rests on Congress, Congress is under no obligation to borrow more if it doesn't think the additional borrowing is a good idea.

To say otherwise is to overrule congressional authority, in contrast to the democratic principles at the core of the federal government design.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.