The problem is that nationalizing an industry puts it under the control of the president.
Don't like #Trump? Don't like #Biden? Whatever team you play for, to nationalize rail is to hand control of it over to that guy.
I'd rather not politicize rail like that, especially considering how badly such presidents bungle even their politicized jobs.
Firstly, the profit incentive is absolutely alive and well in nationalized industries.
You think NASA employees work for free?
But to the point, it sounds like you're trying to have it both ways, saying the industry is already under the control of the federal government--just look at how badly the feds have screwed it up--but what we need now is to put it under the control of the federal government--they'll fix these problems.
No, I'd say the examples you've given here are great examples of why we SHOULDN'T nationalize the industry.
Trump removed regulations and Biden forced people to work, and that's through the regulatory and processes. Imagine what harm they'd do with direct command of the organizations.
@volkris
The industry is already politicized. Trump removed regulations that would have set higher standards for train braking systems. Biden forced the rail workers back to work under a contract they didn't agree to. Like it or not, because Norfolk Southern bought our politicians, it has control over them. If we nationalize the rail system, we remove the profit incentive of Norfolk Southern and wrest control from their executives and lobbyists.