#SCOTUS #Injustice #ClarenceThomas #Ethics #Transparency
If you are sick and tired of the ethical violations of SCOTUS justices, don't just complain on social media--contact your representative and senators. Tell them to support H.R. 926 and S. 359, the Supreme Court Ethics, Recusal and Transparency Act.
No, if a Justice is misbehaving the proper response of the Congress is to impeach them.
These pieces of legislation are the wrong response since it violates the separations of powers structure of the federal government for the Legislative Branch to try to exert power over the independent Judiciary Branch like this.
Impeachment is the sole response available for very good reasons.
@volkris @nancylwayne they don’t have the votes to impeach
Well then that's your answer.
If Congress doesn't have the votes to find that a Supreme Court Justice has misbehaved--if it doesn't have the votes to pierce the firewall against the independent judiciary--then it certainly doesn't have solid ground on which to dictate orders to the Judicial Branch for abstract reasons.
Separation of Powers gives Congress a specific and powerful ability to directly address problematic justices that still protects the judicial independence in general.
If those the people have elected to have that power don't see fit to use it in any particular case, well, that's the determination of the US democratic process.
@volkris @nancylwayne
I’m no constitutional scholar but seems obvious congress would have a hard time finding the votes to impeach if justices are allowed to hide their offenses.
If the offenses of justices are so able to be hidden away, in other words that they are so inoffensive, then there's not really any need to impeach them in the first place.
So this is why we have this system in place, to maintain judicial independence while giving Congress the ability to impeach IF a justice does misbehave in a way that becomes substantial.
So what you're describing is a feature, not a bug, giving justices independence from undue interference in their branch from others seeking power.
Otherwise there'd be nothing to stop powerful congresspeople from hounding the nine into submission.
Well, good thing that's not what I think :)
If any justice is committing major offenses in his private life, fine, that's a matter for the police to investigate just like any other person. Justices have to obey the law just like anyone else.
However, as for their roles as justices on the Court, if a justice is doing their job so inoffensively to the job that Congress can't tell, then it's hard to justify giving Congress so much power over the judiciary that they might go fishing to find offense.
It's like, if you're doing your own job so well that your employer can't see any change in your work, then it's really none of their business what you're doing after business hours.
So far Congress is not particularly unhappy with the work of any of the justices. And therefore, they're not choosing to fire, through impeachment.
@volkris @nancylwayne I’m done here. You seem to think replying with a lot of text excuses the logic errors and stupidity in your prior posts. It doesn’t. Bye