“forcing OpenAI to identify its use of copyrighted data would expose the company to potential lawsuits. Generative AI systems are trained using large amounts of data scraped from the web, much of it copyright protected… [disclosing sources leaves us] open to legal challenges.”

Looking forward to new defences in court saying if they’re forced to explain exactly where they got this car boot stall full of nappies and DVDs from, they’ll be subject to “legal challenges”

theverge.com/2023/5/25/2373711

Like, how is this OK? How is it OK to say "yeah, we did crimes, and if you force us to say what we did, we'll have to say we did crimes", and then nothing else happens? This is like politicians saying "yeah, I did coke, what are you going to do about it" while all around them people are going to prison for the same thing that famous people and big companies can just laugh off.

@sil

Keep in mind that depending on jurisdiction copyright does not mean necessarily that it's illegal to use the content. It's more about effectively claiming ownership of somebody else's content, but you're still free to use it.

So it's not that they did crimes.

@volkris sure. And if they thought that, they'd be arguing for "we're allowed to do this anyway". But "if you make us say what we took, we'll bail on your whole continent rather than do so" may not necessarily guarantee that they know what they did will be viewed to be wrong, but it strongly implies it.

@sil @volkris
It's illegal in the US but unless you've filed with the copyright office they can pretty much say "make me". And even if you have filed they can still just say "make me" because even if you win you're not likely to even cover the cost of lawyers.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.