#Libertarians and fedi misconceptions... 

The fedi loves to hate on libertarians, but (with respect) most of the fedi is ignorant as fuck when it comes to libertarians. I mean, I know 100% that y'all don't agree on economics, but on social issues? I expect you agree on at least 8 of their 9 points. Well. I do.

I think a lot of that hate comes from the whole "OMG THEY ROONT THE ELECTION" from 2016, but reality is that the only spoiler was a lackluster candidate that was so unlikable that she lost to Trump, of all people.

So in the interest of fact versus fiction... here's the Libertarian Party's platform page:

https://www.lp.org/platform/

#Libertarians and fedi misconceptions... 

I know that there are a lot of shitty libertarians out there... I've encountered them too. And I know they make some batshit statements sometimes, have been subverted at times by crap-ass factions. But I don't get the hate because I know where they actually stand... and reality is that they stand a hell of a lot closer to the positions of self-ownership, bodily autonomy, and human rights than ANY candidate fielded by the "top two."

I mean hell, when a pro-war, formerly anti-LGBTQ+ candidate who used to rub elbows with the KKK is your BEST choice, then maybe it's time to talk to other people. We need a ticket with GOOD candidates... or at least candidates who weren't until very recently 100% okay with dehumanizing all of us.

#Libertarians and fedi misconceptions... 

Maybe we need a new party that sits in the middle on economics, is strongly pro-social and civil rights. I'd join that party, because I want a better world... not the same shitty world that the GOP and DNC have been forcing down out throat for years.

And before someone claims it... no, the GOP and the DNC are not the same. The DNC might be sleazy, but the GOP is objectively fucking evil. The DNC might be the better choice, but that does not make them a GOOD choice.

Follow

#Libertarians and fedi misconceptions... 

@Melpomene

Keep in mind that the two party system is a symptom of the fundamental problem with how the US votes, with the winner take all balloting, without ranked choice of any sort.

People naturally organize into parties as they organize themselves to avoid wasted votes, with two parties being the most effective way to do that. It's basically a simulated ranked choice, even if it's not a perfect or very good replacement.

Point is, people calling for a third party are overlooking the problem two parties solve.

The better approach is to shift the two parties in better directions.

Or (and) push for ranked choice voting, but that's a heavier lift.

re: #Libertarians and fedi misconceptions... 

@volkris@qoto.org I'm all for ranked choice voting or something similar, yes. I take issue with the two party system because those two parties are directly responsible for creating the problem... they've effectively locked out other parties from participating in any meaningful way.

This time around, depending on how things look, I'll probably toss in with the DNC because they're the objectively better option. I'll continue to fight for better choices for everyone too, though.

re: #Libertarians and fedi misconceptions... 

@Melpomene

You're missing my point:
Yes, the parties do do underhanded and even unfair things in their self-interests, absolutely.

BUT

Fundamentally other parties are disadvantaged by the math of our voting system.

The two parties didn't create vote splitting. That's created by a system where we have to choose one candidate from a list, and so we have to also guess how our neighbor is going to vote to try to avoid wasting the vote.

THAT's what keeps other parties down, the math involved, regardless of what the Democratic and Republican parties might think of it.

And the funny thing is that with the two party system representing mitigation for this deeper issue, their maintenance becomes as positive thing, in that sense.

re: #Libertarians and fedi misconceptions... 

@volkris@qoto.org the system does play a major role, agree. IF we had two parties that did not actively disenfranchise competition, then I'd be content focusing solely on reforming the underlying issues. But the issue is not JUST the system, the issue is that the people controlling the system have a vested interest in colluding to bar any meaningful change.

But if we could get IRV or RCV? That would be a great start. Don't see the people who benefit the least ever agreeing to that, though.

re: #Libertarians and fedi misconceptions... 

@Melpomene

But we don't need the parties' permission to improve the voting system. If the general public wanted the change, then it would undermine the parties' power, undercutting their relevance, and their protestations wouldn't matter that much.

The problem is that the general public doesn't understand the issue with the voting system.

We see this in response to the use of RCV in Alaska, where so many individuals felt that the outcome was faulty when it delivered results that were better. They didn't understand the system even after it was implemented.

Everything else, including the people controlling the system, hangs on that one issue.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.