Netanyahu reiterating today that no aid workers will enter Gaza until all hostages are released. Collective punishment of the civilian populace is a war crime. Period.

@mcnado it's not, though. That's not how war crimes work, nor is it what you're talking about here.

In general, war crimes only come up when there's a formal war. The Hamas attacks didn't qualify due to how they were carried out, without regular, uniformed soldiers and such. So the law of war isn't really on the table.

But we can go even more basic: it's not collective punishment not to help. It's neutrality.

It's simply factually false to say that the lack of aid is punishment.

Rather, you're accusing a war crime for something people didn't do in a circumstance where law of war doesn't apply.

@volkris he didn’t say “we won’t provide aid”. He is saying he will prevent aid workers coming into Gaza. IDF bombed the crossing from Egypt for days to prevent aid getting in. That isn’t neutrality. I don’t give two fucks if Israel doesn’t provide aid to Gaza. They did establish it as what is basically a prison, so there’s an argument about their responsibility there, but the point is, if they are stopping other people from providing aid in Gaza, that’s a problem.

@mcnado you're still describing the lack of provision of aid.

The details leading up to aid not being provided are separate from the result of the lack of provision of aid.

You can certainly complain that IDF did damage to crossings or aid convoys or whatever, but that doesn't change the outcome, which was neutral.

In other words, HOW neutrality was realized is a different matter from THAT neutrality was realized.

@volkris oh jesus fucking christ. Really?!? Get fucked with that nonsense. IDF isn’t “accidentally” bombing “kinda near” the crossing. They are intentionally closing it. For fuck’s sake…

Anyhow, bombing hospitals is bad. Killing civilians is bad. Preventing aid from reaching the hospitals who care for the civilians you bombed is bad. Telling people to flee to an area, then bombing them, then bombing the hospital, then bombing the aid convoy, is FUCKING BAD.

Follow

@mcnado wow, you're really getting upset over things that I neither say nor believe, positions I wouldn't hold or support.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.