good. fuck airbnb
'Trudeau government to crack down on people who profit from short-term rentals like Airbnb: source'
'Tuesday’s federal fiscal update is expected to prevent property owners from claiming rental expenses in a bid to quash the incentive to flout local short-term rental restrictions.'
@ignova so this screws over both property owners and folks looking for housing.
@volkris ...explain?
@ignova well if you own a house this sounds like it would make it harder for you to get some extra income based on your own property.
And if you need a place to stay in town, this makes it harder for someone to offer you a place to stay.
@ignova have you ever wanted to get a place to stay in another city?
I mean that's a real need.
Setting up these roadblocks to letting people host others in their houses benefits corporate hotels, you realize.
We will have fewer options for finding places to stay outside of the hotel chains with these restrictions.
@ignova so I guess it's time to invest in Hilton.
But really your framing is questionable.
Being able to rent out the house when it's not in use also HELPS a family afford a place to live. It helps to offset the cost of the mortgage.
The family trying to afford a place to live is harmed by these restrictions that limit the way that family can use their property.
So this sort of restriction is really questionable coming and going. That's the point.
@volkris but nothing in the proposed legislation takes away a family's ability to occasionally list a house on airbnb. the legislation is about eliminating a tax break that was providing an incentive for people to flout local restrictions on short term rentals. and it only does so for municipalities who already restrict these short term rentals anyway.
@ignova eliminating that tax break IS interfering with a family's ability to list their property.
Doubling down on municipalities' restrictions that limit how a family can make some money with what they own is the problem.
It can't just be hand waved away by saying it's "just" doing that. Doing that is an issue.
@volkris i guess i don't see the closing of a tax loophole as an intolerable infringement on human rights when it has the potential to mitigate a bigger-picture crisis. unless you have something to support the idea that the legislation will cause a bigger scale problem than it will solve (i.e. that cost will outweigh benefit) i'd consider this use case to be an eggshell broken on the way to making an omelet.
@ignova I never said it was intolerable.
Taxation is a necessary evil to fund government in a modern society.
However, as we set tax policy we need to balance the real world implications and the real world impacts of the tax regimes that we settle on.
So this will make it harder for families to afford houses, and it will make it harder for travelers to find places to stay, but maybe we decide that those are acceptable costs to fund the social programs that we find important.
It's fine to make that trade off. We just have to be conscious of the costs as we do.
@volkris corporate hotels are not the villains of the housing crisis. if the cost of more families being able to afford a place to live is that travellers have to spend more money on hotels then...so what?