On xbird, Japan Astronaut Noguchi noted that both new launch vehicles for #SpaceX and #JAXA, Starship & H3, successfully completed the 1st rocket stage and failed during the 2nd. But the response was WILDLY different.

Truthfully, when I read about the "successful" spaceX launch, I thought "who are their PR team, who turned RUD into RAD?!"

JAXA did lose the onboard ALOS-3 satellite, so the consequences were worse. But the "failure" has weighed heavily on JAXA. SpaceX seem to be raving the RUD 🤔

@elizabethtasker consider that as a private company maybe SpaceX just isn't as concerned with PR and informing the public as the politicized agency is.

The Starship launch was a success because it met the goals of the launch. True, not everyone in the general public was up to speed about how the launch program was proceeding, so a lot of people aren't aware of what the goals were.

Maybe SpaceX is more interested in focusing on the engineering mission than public outreach. That seems pretty reasonable to me.

A whole lot of us who follow the development, though, understand why the launch is seen as a success because we knew ahead of time what their goals were and we watched them accomplish their goals.

@volkris On the contrary, I'm very impressed by the SpaceX outreach! They turned something that would by default be seen as a failure (a rocket blowing up) into a declared success, and this was reflected in the resulting articles I saw on the news which followed the PR lead.

Part of the difference is also cultural, with Japan being more inclined to acknowledge any failure. But it's a pity we can't cheer on and focus on the success a bit more, like Space X.

Follow

@elizabethtasker perhaps I misunderstood your post.

There has been so much hate thrown at SpaceX for the last few days, based on misunderstandings of the development process, and it's been a shame.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.