I'm sorry, but the investigative journalism work done by Tortoise Investigates is ten times better than any of the limited series coming out regularly through the NYT/Serial/This American Life arm. I spent the afternoon binge-listening HOAXED, a completely insane and mesmerizing look into an invented pedophile ring (think Pizzagate on steroids) that even penetrated the House of Commons (and took the show's reporters to Morocco). It's truly a vital wakeup call on how conspiracy theories can turn anyone insane. I highly recommend it.
@edwardchampion frankly, I've never figured out why anybody thinks NYT/Serial/This American Life is particularly good journalism, investigative or otherwise.
I know they put splashy editing and fancy sounds to dress up their productions, but on the substance, they're pretty much crap.
@edwardchampion ha, Yeah and my just personal preference is, I hate all of that tinkly stuff 🙂
My personal preference is to have dry, university lecture style content. Like, if you mention a train, you don't have to put a train horn in there, I know what a train is!
All the sound effects and fancy editing really take me out of the raw information that I want to learn from the production.
Anyway, that's just my personal gripe 🙂
More substantially, style aside, I just don't think they do good work, I think they do a mediocre job and then dress their work up with all of the silly sound effects.
I think that serial had potential but they sort of didn't do as much with it as they could have, they were aiming for an accessible, popular product, and that held them back.
@volkris The one thing I'll add is that there isn't enough playful sound design out there. And obviously that's very hard to do when the tone is serious. On the other hand, I find this to be a significant tonal limitation to the audio medium. I put in work every day to ensure that there's even a kernel of playfulness to everything I do, even when I'm being stone-cold serious. The big podcast companies are completely against this (I've had meetings with these often humorless people), which is why I've stayed independent. It simply isn't worth the hassle. I would rather lose money doing something I love than to create more content for the sake of content, which is regrettably the raison d'etre of 90% of podcasts.
@edwardchampion sure, like I said, just a personal preference of mine.
@volkris You're talking with a rare guy who swings many ways on the audio production front. Meaning audio drama, straight interviews where the conversation is the thing, and full-bore documentary. I think the best thing for ALL audio formats to do is to be as real as possible, to err on the side of verisimilitude. (And, yes, that even includes moments when a giant bird creature creates havoc in Midtown, which was a very fun set piece to put together.) I agree with you that a podcast or radio audience is intelligent enough to be SUBMERGED and that the quality of the conversation or the sound design should reflect something akin to Hemingway's iceberg theory. Though I am in the minority here. Obviously there are moments in which you need to take a melodramatic sound design swing for the sake of theatre. But if it's gratuitous and the sound design isn't devoted to complete submergence, then you're probably doing audio production very wrong.