“The problem is, there’s a certain type of pedantry that has followed the internet through its various forms, especially in more technical channels, and it often creates a negative experience because it seems to be driven by ideology or disdain for people who don’t think the same way.” https://tedium.co/2023/11/21/mastodon-reply-guy-problem/
@taylorlorenz one really important thing to keep in mind is that different people simply like different things and want different experiences from social media.
It's hard to say that Mastodon has a reply guy problem when there are users who actually want that experience, so for them it's not a problem at all. It's the expected functionality, it's a feature not a bug.
With that in mind I think the Mastodon response is backwards.
Mastodon seems to be following this long approach that fails to empower each user to craft their own experience as they see fit, in terms of what they want out of the platform.
To describe this as a problem, even though many users may want it, is another case of one size fits all thinking that puts the power to shape experience in somebody else's hands.
I just really think we should call #Mastodon out on this and push them to change direction.
It's the same as resistance to #QT and other decisions where developers feel it's their place to tell everybody how they are to use the platform.
@whereami so I'm noticing that you are engaging in exactly the thing I was calling out, ignoring users' abilities to shape their experience the way they want.
@volkris She’s trying to shape everyone else’s experience on the platform to suit herself. I will continue to call that out when I see it.
If someone joins a community and immediately starts trying to impose their own rules on it contrary to the community’s existing practices, that’s a red flag.
@volkris It’s not surprising to me that people whose egos were made abnormally large by their enormous bot follower count on Twitter come here and start demanding that they should be able to preemptively gag the community and just post their Thought Leadership at us. They’re taking a community and trying to turn it into their passive audience.