When I was very young and new to math I remember being very fascinated with repeating decimals, things like this

\[0.121212121212...\]

for the rest of this post I will use the bar notation and represent the above as this which is the same thing:

\[0.\overline{12}\]

Anyway what I found curious as a kid was that you can represent an infinitely repeating decimal as a fraction where it is just the repeating bit of decimals over the same number of digits of 9. So the fraction form of the above looks like this

\[\frac{12}{99}\]

This blew my mind as a kid, it seemed almost magical how denominators of multiples of 10 were for "regular" decimals and denominators of 9 were for repeating decimals. What is this voodoo!

Of course it didnt take me long to put two and two together and realize that the fraction \(\frac{9}{9}\) results in 1 and not \(0.\overline{9}\) as the above naive rules might expect.

Of course I went to the math teacher to try to get some help understanding this and having a math teacher try to explain to a kid in first or second grade that \(0.\overline{9}\) is actually the same as \(1\) wasn't easy for him I'm sure.

I remember his logical point was "well you cant have an infinitely small number, so if the 9's go on forever they are just approaching 1". As an adult looking back I realize he was thinking of it in calculus terms, which is all well and valid, but it didnt translate too well to a little kid. I remember coming back tot he teacher the next day, smug as hell, ready to prove him wrong and I came up with this equation:

\[0.\overline{9} = 1 - 0.\overline{0}1\]

He said "you cant do that" I replied "I just did!"

As an adult knowing limits and all that I understand what the teacher was saying, and of course he was right in a way. But then even older as I got deeper in math I learned of the concept of an infinitesimal, which is basically the very idea I was conveying as a kid just in a less refined way, without good wording. So now I look back and dont know if my teacher was outsmarted by child-me, or what.

Follow

@freemo math is futile, all representation is approximation. :)

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.