This article is well worth reading, but I want to make one little correction.

There is a definite link between criticism of Israel's oppression of Palestinians and antisemitism, but it is wildly irresponsible to suggest that all criticism of the way Israel treats Palestinians is inherently antisemitic.

I hope you're already aware of the "pipeline" that starts with edgy anti-SJW "humor" that leads to all-out fascism. It works on gracias steps, and those on…

jewishcurrents.org/harvard-is-

1/

…the path don't realize it until they are hip deep in white supremacy.

There is a similar "pipeline" that targets leftists and liberals, and it starts with genuine criticism of how Israel treats Palestinians. Little by little, the criticisms of Israel branches out to other topics, until eventually, the person is spewing Nazi conspiracy theories about George Soros and other nonsense. I've seen it happen on social media.

The things being shared on one's feed gets more and more unhinged.

2/

The pipeline appears to be smaller than the "politically incorrect" pipeline that sucks in people from the right, but it's worth pointing out that there is a pipeline that targets us, and sometimes, it really does work.

I feel it is worthwhile to point this out and warn people, and mention that it is irresponsible for this article to make it sound like that doesn't happen.

But I also want to mention that I've seen this happen with a grand total of two people on a platform…

3/

…that includes a lot of Nazis and relatively little moderation.

Out of all the people I have seen criticize Israel over their treatment of Palestinians, only two people ended up sucked down a path that led to spewing Nazi conspiracy theories. From my admittedly anecdotal observations, it is incredibly rare.

Cryptofascists can turn up anywhere. Yes, it is inconsistent that they both celebrate Israel for what they do to Palestinians and criticize them for it. They say whatever will…

4/

…ingratiate them with their current audience. They don't actually care about or believe half of the words they vomit onto the Internet.

I just wanted to warn people.

The liberal/left-to-fascism pipeline may be smaller than the right-to-fascism pipeline, but it does exist, and if you're not aware of it, you could be more vulnerable to it.

If you start seeing broader and more unhinged criticisms of Israel in your feed from new contacts, pay extra attention, please.

5/

Warn others if you see it happening to them.

Again, I want to stress that I am in no way saying that all criticism of Israel is antisemitic. That is a wildly irresponsible (not to mention pro-genocide) thing to say.

6/6

Follow

@tofugolem
"Warn others when you see it happening to them" will get you blocked by those you warn. Deja vu.

@ClaraListensprechen4
The second time I saw it, I decided to speak up rather than just blocking the person.

So I commented on the more demented shares that obviously came from fascists, and pointed out how unhinged the conspiracy theories were.

The person agreed that the shares were unhinged and Nazi-like, but kept sharing the bullshit anyway, so I eventually blocked him as well.

Normally, I am eager to argue with crazies, but not after watching someone descend into madness.

@tofugolem
While it may be a tragedy, it is also a case of the person making a conscious choice. There's no arguing a person out of making bad choices.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.