Mastodon Rant
@Jessica
2, 3, & 4 don't seem connected either, all of them appear as individual toots to me, none of them appear as replies below any of the others. Are you using the website or an app? Can you describe how you're doing the thread?
Mastodon Rant
@Jessica
I just installed Tusky to try it out, and the same procedure seems to be working fine for me: https://qoto.org/@digital_carver/109331371663904789
As @indianautistic says, it's good practice to make the replies unlisted, just avoid spamming timelines, but that's separate from the posts not being threaded together. I made all my posts Public (not Unlisted) just to test this out too, and they're threaded together despite not being Unlisted.
Mastodon Rant
@digital_carver @indianautistic Wow, I don't understand what I did wrong 😖
At this point I don't even know if I should delete and redraft them all again unlisted, I feel like I'd make even more mistakes.
Mastodon Rant
@Jessica @digital_carver it’s ok! Your workaround is cool and maybe newer threads will be fine but you don’t have to redo stuff
Mastodon Rant
@digital_carver @Jessica strange, maybe an app update would fix it Jessica?