We take a VERY serious approach to racism and hate speech. We have and do actively block anyone who has expressed hate speech.
Our rules also explicitly state this.
Do you have any examples of something one of our users have posted that you feel should have been moderated? If so please just make a report we can and will take any such reports seriously.
I see why this thread is concerning. He does seem confrontational and there were social hints dropped that his comments were not welcome or intrusive.
Certainly a lack of delicacy there.
Not trying to blame you at all but for my own understanding was this post originally local only or public? I ask because if it were local only he really had to go out of his way to find it in the first pace.
Yea I suspect part of it is he is just passionate about the issue. Ther eis a lot of frivolous banning going around (people banning instances just because the instance does not ban some other instance). I know he was personally affected by this trend and lost touch with many friends.
I suspect that because he was following someone he interjected, and just might be a bit numb to the social cues that he was not welcomed.
I suspect he really didnt mean any harm its just his passion came through in how he conducted himself and he just didnt realize he was doing anything wrong.
Maybe i am giving him too much credit, what do you think?
Regardless I think it might help to talk with him and maybe give him some advice on how to be a little more sensitive.
Do you think I'd be going too easy here or do you think that would be a good way to handle it?
Yea i the end once he realized what was going on he seemed compassionate and understanding. I do feel he had good intentions. I'm really happy we could work this out.
I am sure in the future now that he is aware he will be more mindful.
No need to be sorry at all. If there is one thing I recognize from my trans friends it is that the trans community an be treated quite brutally by others and I understand any defensiveness that might create. It would be important to me to ensure your members feel respected by ours, in fact it is our number one rule, to respect others and show compassion.
As such I think there are going to be some people with ill intent. I think they are fairly rare on QOTO (at least I hope so) but when they do happen we will step in quickly to act.
I think there may be some other people who have the best of intentions but simply dont understand how what they say or do may make someone else uncomfortable. For that I cant think of any way to really handle it other than to hope that when it does happen someone will speak up (perhaps to an admin if needed) and we can help show why a user doing what they did wasnt particularly considerate. If they are a truly kind person they would recognize this and adjust their behavior in the future.
With that said, I am not trans, I will not presume to know what a trans person might be made uncomfortable by, im not even sure if there is a single answer to this. So I would rely on you and others int he trans community to help us learn so we can improve and take that into consideration. For at least some people it is more ignorance than anything willfully hostile. The only way to address ignorance is to help expose these people more and hopefully get them to learn how to be a better friend to those in the trans community.
I welcome any advice you might have on how I can better hope to achieve these goals and help ensure the trans community feels safe and loved by all those at QOTO.
@Breakfast
i did have a user from there come into a conversation about blocking other instances like freespeechextremist, and looking at their profile, that seems to be a lot of what they do, without any regard as to why we do these things. ive gone through the public timeline there and dont really see much else, but it raises some concern for me as an admin of an instance like mine which mostly consists of trans girls who have dealt with a lot of shit from people on free speech communities and want as little of it in our mentions as we realistically can, whether it be political or not
of course, that is only one user. my read on the ruleset combined with that one experience has left me with an impression that it *may* be an attractive place for people to start debates about our personal choices, maybe even heatedly so. thats not harassment, but its a concerning behavior that we've dealt with in our lives and choose to avoid as much as possible from those experiences.
im sorry if my post came off as a call to block the instance, i was expressing my discomfort about it very bluntly.