@noelle 2 is true, 1 is not.
@freemo It certainly is. I've seen it personally.
@noelle It can happen if the ice freezes unevenly and you get air gaps, but it is not a garuntee or even the norm. Under ideal circumstances that would not happen for several reasons..
Its the reason why most ice cubes that come out of the freezer doesnt have a bubble in it, though it occasionally can.
@noelle The exception where water wil form under the ice (what you observed) occurs typically where ice freezes slowly, getting an ice later then the cold reduces the ability of the water to dissolve air and thus tiny bubbles are released. If the freezing cycle is just right this can cause a air pocket just under the suface of the ice. But typically that is not hte case.
Typically what you get is either 1) no air of any kind (the result of water that is not aerated) or 2) you get some bubbles but they appear as a white "cloud" in the ice rather than a coherent bubble as they only came out of solution when most of the water had already frozen.
In neither case is the resulting air, however, due to the expansion of the ice itself, which actually forms an airtight seal around the water presuming it is cooled from all sides.