@static I am not asserting free will exists or not, I haven't even decided what definition it could have that would even be testable. But since you seem certain it doesn't exist I presume you have some reasoning for that?

@freemo Thats one of my simple points, no one can really make a plausible definition for it while it's quite simple to build a model for the antithesis

@static If you cant define it then no one could model a thesis **or** antithesis for it equally. You cant say something doesnt exist if you havent defined what that something is.

@freemo What I'm saying is that it's very easy to talk about how a world without "free will" may operate but not so much a world with it. The void created by its consideration is not easily written off -- nor is it a necessary thing to worry about on a metaphysical level, "why did person y do thing z."
Follow

@static Since you have yet to define the phrase "free will" in any technical way... no it isnt.

You cant talk about a world without free will at all if you havent bothered to define free will. What if i define free will to mean "muffins" then obviously you would be wrong.

If you derive conclusions of **any** kind without a definition then you arent really saying anything at all.

@freemo I am promoting the position that "free will" is not a phrase with meaning and thus I have no duty to define it. I am arguing precisely that "free will" is not a position to entertain when discussing the world.

@static Thats fair, So your stance is **not** that free will doesnt exist.

Seems reasonable then.

@freemo My stance is that believers in free will have not served their duty in establishing its existence nor proving its necessity.

@static And presumably if you agree that "Free Will" is not defined ina technically useful way then you also feel the same is true in reverse. That believers in the lack of free will have not served their duty in establishing its existence nor proving its necessity, as a result of that same lack of definition.

If that is not yoru stance then your logic still has a gaping flaw in it.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.