@papush@niu.moe

I disagree, as would most starving artists who rely on copyright law and people paying for their art to feed themselves. As well as many inventors and innovators.

@DissidentKitty@radical.town

@freemo @papush >starving artists

Yes because they weren't already starving. Piracy is commonly used as a form of objection to large record / movie / distribution companies which often don't respect both the artist and the end-consumer, and is basically another form of "voting with your wallet".

By doing so we are basically sending the big shots the message that we don't like them, and artists the message to seek a different means of distribution. Piracy means that we like the music and the artist, but aren't willing to participate in the nonsense often mandated by the big companies.

Simply the act of trying to knock out these big companies acts as a justification, even if the artists ends up suffering from it too. However, piracy does give one thing to the artist nonetheless: recognition. Pirated distribution does still give the artist name and fame, which can be helpful to them still.

@fristi

You're basically saying "I dont like that these big companies steal 90% from the creators, therefore I will steal 100% fromt he creators because I am the good guy"

@papush@niu.moe

@freemo @papush I'm not taking 100%. I'm refusing to buy, but allowing the creator their deserved name and fame. You simply refuse to acknowledge there is more to this than profits and copyright.

I'm also not denying that this may harm the creator. But the creator still has the power to remedy that, by moving to a different distribution platform that DOES respect the creator and the end-consumer. That is the goal.

@fristi

As long as your willing to admit that you are ok with causing harm to the creator, steal from them, and do so for mostly selfish/greedy reasons, then thats fine by me.

I am not trying to guilt anyone who engages in piracy, I just dont like when people act out of personal greed and then try to frame it as a good deed, it isnt.

@papush@niu.moe

@freemo @papush please, don't try to put words into my mouth.

>causing harm to the creator
As I explained, that can happen as a side effect. Do we like that? No. But it's a means of sending a message. If the creator understands that message, they can do something about it to prevent the harm.

>steal from them
you_keep_using_that_word.jpg
Whether I would pirate the content or not, there would be no sale; and no profit for the creator. I decide not to buy; the creator ultimately ends up not getting profit from me, regardless from if I end up pirating the content or not. Look at it this way; if nobody pirated, but continued to not buy copies, the creator would earn nothing. This would give the erroneous message that the content was bad somehow; it would steer the creator in the wrong way and it could cause further harm down the line. By pirating, the creator is presented a different message; people want their content, but are not prepared to deal with whatever distribution method is used.

>do so for selfish/greed reasons
As I said, don't put words in my mouth. You're directly implying I should just be a slave to whatever the distribution companies desires are, agreeing to whatever DRM nonsense is forced upon me. No, I won't do that.
If a creator decides to use a proper distribution platform, the chance is pretty high that I would buy legitimate copies of their work; there's no reason to pirate then. By doing what I do, I'm trying to invoke a change in the world, if even a minor one; to give back power to the creators and end-consumers. Do I do so out of the good of my heart? I'll agree that I go this route because it helps me, too. But ultimately this is a win-win solution for both creators and end-consumers, where the -actually greedy- companies in the middle are eliminated.

@fristi

If you want to have any skin in this game then start sending the cost you would have paid direct to the artist when you pirate.

Unless and until you do that you don't have a leg to standon and its just an elaborate justification for greed and theft.

This is the last comment I'll make on this. You're welcome to give any closing remarks if you wish but past that please untag me int he conversation.

@papush@niu.moe

@freemo @papush

It's sad that there's no way of expanding your view on these matters. I've properly explained my viewpoints on this, but it's up to you to read and contemplate on them; if you have no such desire to do so, there's little point in this conversation.

It's also sad that you're so bent on painting a picture over me while you yourself don't care to provide valid arguments or counter-arguments, and continue to display such a stiff mindset. You're free to think as you wish, but I can guarantee you that nobody will ever agree to your points if you keep presenting them like this.

Good luck in your future endeavors.

@fristi

You're points are nothing new. I've considered it myself many times. You assume you are right, as most people do, and that because I disagree with you that I must be stiff or unwilling to consider your point. You seem to fail to consider that I did contemplate your point and simply found it weak and invalid.

I started my career in piracy, I helped define the laws on piracy in the early days of the internet because I was the creator of one of the earliest piracy software out there with millions of users and had to defend it against a lawsuit with major corperations (like SEGA).

Trust me when I say I have spent a LOT of time considering my stance. I used to think and feel as you do, but i learned that I was wrong and change my views (further proving my mentality is far from ridgid or unwilling to consider other points).

Sometimes your just wrong, sometimes your right and people consider your views and make the wrong call. Either way you clearly feel you have some superior opinion and anyone who doesnt agree with you must be dysfunctional in their ability to consider your view. Sorry the world isnt that simple.

I've heard your rebuttal, now please do not tag me again on this topic, thank you.

@papush@niu.moe

@freemo @papush

>Sometimes your just wrong, sometimes your right and people consider your views and make the wrong call. Either way you clearly feel you have some superior opinion and anyone who doesnt agree with you must be dysfunctional in their ability to consider your view. Sorry the world isnt that simple.

I have merely explained my reasoning, and why I think your reasoning is wrong. But that doesn't mean I'm not open to suggestion. It's just that you haven't actually suggested anything in this entire thread but to paint me off as greedy or selfish, because you can't look beyond your own reasoning.

Very well, I see there's very little point in keeping this going. I've got better things to do. Goodbye.
Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.