@snow @freemo I don't buy this value system either
but the fact is that if 5 people and 1 person are equally valuable, then both choices would be the same, so I'd need something else to go by to make the decision
and number-of-people seems like the most obvious alternate basis for the decision even if it doesn't have a solid philosophical underpinning
As I stated earlier the decision has nothing to do with value. It has to do with preventing suffering of the individuals regardless of what value they have or dont have.
@snow
@freemo @snow well that's a perfectly legitimate system, but then what you value is non-suffering so it's still a value-system imo
(if the definition of "what you value in a value-system" is "the thing that you desire to increase so much it informs all of your moral decisions", which is what I mean by it)