@snow @freemo I don't buy this value system either

but the fact is that if 5 people and 1 person are equally valuable, then both choices would be the same, so I'd need something else to go by to make the decision

and number-of-people seems like the most obvious alternate basis for the decision even if it doesn't have a solid philosophical underpinning

@snow @freemo you could also say, though, that if you considered 1 person and 5 people to be perfectly equally valuable and didn't consider any other system you could make a decision based on (like number-of-people) to be useful, and your default choice when all courses of action were equivalent was to do nothing, then it would lead you to choose inaction.

(I mean that's not the reason you gave of not wanting to be a murderer, but I realized this is also a valid reason to do nothing)

Follow

@codepuppy

As I stated earlier the decision has nothing to do with value. It has to do with preventing suffering of the individuals regardless of what value they have or dont have.

@snow

@freemo @snow well that's a perfectly legitimate system, but then what you value is non-suffering so it's still a value-system imo

(if the definition of "what you value in a value-system" is "the thing that you desire to increase so much it informs all of your moral decisions", which is what I mean by it)

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.