5G Cellphone Towers Do Generate More Radiation Than 4G But NOT Because Of 5G Frequencies - Thorough Investigation Is Still Needed Into Downlink RF Exposure To Humans

I did a post about a week back about 5G towers not having any evidence of killing birds and quite a debate erupted across a few of my networks about it. I've dug a lot deeper since and can now clarify some differences that are really important to consider, and why my statement about 5G towers giving off LESS radiation was not correct:
* 5G as a frequency around 85GHz has LESS skin/body penetration than lower frequencies if all things are equal like antenna and power output (that's a simple radio fact that some have got wrong - see Ref 1 below).
* Cellphone towers don't have a single omni-directional antenna (this is what I did not account for and things are therefore not "equal") as they have arrays of over 100 beam-forming antennas.
* 5G towers will be in closer proximity than 4G (and earlier) to make up for the less penetration challenge. This point and the one point above means yes there is overall more radiation than with 3G or 4G. squeet.me/objects/962c3e1016d7

Follow

@danie10 Seems to be a lot of misinformation here all around so I want to clarify a few things.

The ERIP for 5G's 28GHz band is ~43-46 dBm for current towers being tested, the FCC legal limit is 55 dBm. Here is one such test report for an Ericson tower.

fccid.io/TA8AKRD901059-1/RF-Ex

The ERIP for a typical 4G LTE tower however is much more with typical emissions being around 53dBm and maximum at 64 dBm (remember these are logarithmically scaled so thats a HUGE increase).

ntia.doc.gov/files/ntia/meetin

EIRP already accounts for directionality so it isnt hard to see that the effective radiation when standing right in the middle of the beam is going to be much much less for 5G than it is for 4G.

We are talking about an effective maximum power output of 2,511 watts for a 4G LTE station and 316 watts for a 5G station. Or in terms of typical power that would be 199 watts equivalent for 4G LTE and 40 watts equivalent for 5G.

No matter how you slice it the effective exposure on 5G is in fact several orders of. magnitude less.

@freemo Wow thanks this is really interesting as I'd not seen the tower tets before and that US study did not actually reference a typical one. So yes I would also think the power could have been less than 4G if towers were closer. Interesting too to see they test as close as 1,8m where the public would normally be a good 10 to 20m at the closest.

The US study mentioned around just over 100 antenna in an array (an array having a few panels) so @freemo do you think there is something incorrect then on that US study with regards to assumptions on the tower antenna array?

Yes those Watts figures you gave make more sense then with an array, and they will usually not be max as the tower adjusts power downwards when cellphones are nearby.

It was the arrays and beam-forming that were not clear to me, as I;'m in no doubt a 5G transmission is generally going to have less penetration and energy than an equal powered 4G signal.

@danie10 100 antennas on a single 5G tower is very atypical. Though keep in mind 5G includes both 28gHz and 5Ghz bands that it can and will switch between as needed. In all reality to penetrate walls it will likely switch over to the 5gHz frequencies rather than pumping the power all the way up which would be less effective.

The whole more towers thing is a valid statement but for opposite reasons. Even with 4G the tendency is to move towards more towers at lower power and that is no different than with 5G. You might think with more towers that means more radiation but in fact the opposite is true.

Back int he earlier days of cell phones we had fewer towers. Each tower was obligated for a larger area. As such the individual towers had super high power output. This meant if you were far away from one the power would be pretty low, but if you were standing close to one the power would be massive and potentially harmful over long periods of time..

Because more towers correlate with lower power what you see is that the power distribution is simply more uniform. You don't have people at the fringes with bad reception and almost no power exposure, but you also don't have people living near a tower in a RF hot spot, if your near a tower its not all that much worse handie talkie. So it means there is no real risk of unhealthy exposure no matter how close you are to the antenna. It also means less interference woes.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.