Here's a brilliant comment about the affordability of a universal basic income. #ubi

I briefly studied the Dutch welfare system while in uni (from a Foucauldian perspective, it was 🔥🔥), and saw up close how people were being stomped on and degraded just to receive some funds to survive. It's a horribly inhumane system. Hopefully the #covid19 pandemic provides us with an opportunity to look at alternatives.

reddit.com/r/australia/comment

Follow

@Gina I live int he netherlands, can you give an example of that? Personally I find the welfare system here quite generous and based on who I see getting help and to what extent, seems to be a good balance of helping those in need, but also expecting them to be actively doing what they should to get out of their situation as a condition of that support.

I'd welcome any counter examples but I do not see the abuse you describe and the friends I know on welfare havent mentioned anything like that.

@freemo our welfare system absolutely isn't the worst compared to others in the world. But the premise is still that people have to jump through loads of hoops, causing loads of stress, especially the weakest in society. The UWV (org for benefits) especially.

Humanity is lost at the UWV (old article from 2015) volkskrant.nl/economie/menseli

De Correspondent also did research: decorrespondent.nl/8094/waarom

Here is a whole series about the ineffectiveness of the UWV: volkskrant.nl/nieuws-achtergro

@freemo I worked at the largest foodbank in the Netherlands for a few years as a evaluator. Aka every 6 months participants had to come back and have their financial situation evaluated to see if they were still eligible. The horror stories I heard there..

There's a whole industry surrounding poor people, that sort of helps them but also makes their lives absolutely miserable. Look at the Schuldig documentary for examples: human.nl/schuldig/over-schuldi

It doesn't have to be this way.

@freemo besides that I also think it would help to simplify our terribly convoluted tax system. Away with all the benefits, and the stress of filing taxes and earning just a little over the social housing or healthcare limit and having to pay it ALL back.

@Gina I agree with reform but I take a very difference stance. IMO the easiest and fairest system would simply be to do away with income tax of any kind and move it over entierly to sales tax (which would need to changes in the netherlands too to ensure essentials arent taxed and that there is a broader range of class of goods with different taxes)

@Gina Horrible. I am at whiz at science but I am clearly mentally stinted when it comes to learning a language.

@freemo if it makes you feel better, I wouldn't wish learning Dutch on my worst enemies. It's a garbage language that makes no sense.

@Gina Eh all languages are mostly nonsense. My issue with dutch is you have way too many vowel sounds to the point that many words sound identical to me.

@Gina @freemo Couldn't agree more / helemaal mee eens! (as a native Dutch speaker)

@Gina Thanks I'll read these on my flight on monday, I appreciate you sharing it.

From my perspective there should be hoops to jump though, to a point.

I dont think it should be a high stress or difficult to cut through the red tape, that process should be easy and not require a lawer. Show up and have someone work with you to go through the process.

But I do think it absolutely should be the case that there are hoops, we want to make sure people arent getting free money unless they are actively improving themself in a way that ensures they wont be dependent on that money (schooling, work training, psychiatrist, whatever it takes). I also think the government should provide help in paying for those things. In fact, the help should be much greater in those areas than otherwise. The help should also be cut back when someone doesnt meet those obligations in my mind.

With all that said I will say I do agree to some extent on your points. Dealing with the Dutch government can be a bit unfair and difficult and that needs to change. I recently got residency here and tried to do the process myself to save some money. Desptite going through all the paperwork and taling to them every step of the way it was rejected and they really didnt provide me much advice as to why or how. At the time i was applying for a meidcal exemption as I just had spinal surgery and my dutch doctor said I could not fly under any circumstances and my stay was still rejected.

Then I got a lawyer, cost me thousands of dollars, but he filed one piece of paper, barely put in any effort, and now I have a residency card... I am lucky I can afford that, but someone who cant would have been screwed, and I'm not even talking about assistance!

@freemo @Gina

IMO and IME, stress is the BIG problem. If you violate any terms the penalties are severe. Keep in mind, this is the last stop. If you don't get it, you will not have money for housing or food. None.

"Everyone has to know the law"
All well and good, but nobody really does.
If you knowingly/purposely violate the terms/conditions, punish those people.
But not knowing (for sure) whether you complied with all terms/conditions is horrible for your stress level.

@FreePietje

fair, and that should be addressed.

In my view the system should allow for infinite chances, but be conditional.

If you are starving but arent doing you part, you get food and water, maybe a bed where you have to share a room, but thats about it by default.

However also make schools and work training programs free (for everyone) and indicate if you wish to qualify for greater level of support (for example instead of living in a room with 3 other people you want your own small studio apartment to rent)... then for that you must be actively attending schooling of some kind.

@Gina

@freemo
Sounds fair to me.
All the people I've met were (very) willing to do something in return* to the best of their capabilities.

Getting rid of (or reducing as much as possible) the stress wrt money and thus food/housing, would increase the chances of ppl on welfare getting out of it and making a new start, substantially.

*) I prefer voluntarily as opposed to mandatory as that has a positive psychological impact

@Gina

@FreePietje

I think you have a few types of welfare seekers

1) Those who want to contribute but cant due to disability

2) Those who dont contribute, and dont try to, they want to but likely just need some guidance from a psych to get on track, but some of these people may not be ready to help themselves

3) those that do contribute but simply fell on hard times or dont have the opportunities to get ahead

#1 and #3 are easy enough to address, the problem is sorting out who is #2, these people are harder to help and sometimes may be beyond help. Sometimes living in poverty may be what they need to finally seek the help.

@Gina

Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.