I know I talk alot of shit about trump, and I really dont like him much. But I must admit, he has done an amazing job handling the coronavirus so far.

Here are some of the things he has done that I am fairly pleased with:

1) Every year he has been in office he signed into law year-after-year budget increases for the CDC

2) He quickly barred incoming flights from both china and europe once cases became significant

3) he quickly issued a state of emergency and orderer the deployment of a US navy quarantine ship to help

4) His administration approved covering all costs for mandatory medical testing and quarinting for COVID-19 patients...

5) He issued a 1,000$ UBI to all american citizens to help alleviate financial problems.

He definitely did a better job than the last few presidents did when handling H1N1 and SARS.

@freemo @lnxw37a2

Supporters and apologists of Trump can't be attacked at a moral, human level. And, yes, give credit where credit is due. However, the obvious shortcomings of Trump and his administration HAVE to be accepted, not sugar-coated, and scrutinized by ALL. This includes many Trump supporters whom he screwed over by installing nothing but lobbyists and billionaires who promote nothing more than *crony capitalism*. I say this as a captialist, the system can't continue to be rigged -- no matter if you're left, right, or center.

@mobius

Your main point about installing lobbyists and billionairs for cronyism is valid, and certainly something Trump is guilty for. But to be fair so were the clintons, hillary, Bush, all the presidents.

Hell even sanders lived on welfare his whole life, destitute and poor, then became a career politician and is now a multi-millionaire...

Not that it makes it right but your literally describing every politician and president with very few exaceptions.

@lnxw37a2

@freemo @mobius @lnxw37a2 > Hell even sanders lived on welfare his whole life, destitute and poor, then became a career politician and is now a multi-millionaire...

this isn't really true. he didn't live off of welfare, he held many jobs - and "career politician" is very different from being a crony capitalist.

just because other people are bad doesn't mean Trump isn't far far worse. I don't like Clintons or Bushes or Gores (Nader 2000!) or even Obamas that much because of their crony capitalism... but each of them are far far better than Trump.
@mewmew @freemo @lnxw37a2 @mobius Out of all of those that you listed, Gore and Nader were the only two who are not war criminals. Liking any of them with the exception of the aforementioned two is not a reasonable thing to do.

Bush 2 was undeniably worse than Trump. Bush 1 is only equivalent to Trump if you don't think being the director of the CIA in one of its objectively most harmful eras pushes him down on the list.
@kick @freemo @lnxw37a2 @mobius I wasn't likening Nader with the others - I'm a fan of Nader. Gore wasn't a war criminal but he also was not elected president.
@mewmew @freemo @lnxw37a2 @mobius Nader was cool. I like Gore because he represents my own political preferences (outside of the climate thing): socially conservative, fiscally conservative, but classy about it.
@kick @freemo @lnxw37a2 @mobius that's fair. Either of them would've been better than Bush (admittedly a low bar).
@mewmew @freemo @lnxw37a2 @mobius A muskrat with a coke problem would have been a better president than Bush. At least the muskrat won't authorize illegal wars!
@mewmew @freemo @lnxw37a2 @mobius The Bushes are the fifth and sixth-worst Presidents, in reverse-chronological order.

@mewmew @freemo @lnxw37a2 @mobius There’s a bit of background required before this (let’s be honest, controversial) idea can even make sense within the current Overton Window. Portions will be omitted from said background because no state I inhabit (nor any United State for that matter) has legalized the substance in question. However, because tax evasion is de-facto legal in the United States, I’ll substitute it in-place.

I was enjoying a relaxing night of conversation and tax evasion with one of my closest friends, someone I think of as almost a sister to me. Incredibly brilliant person.

We get into politics; she’s got a very strange political stance on almost everything. It’d be funny, if it didn’t make sense every time it was explained.

She slights Jefferson at some point during the conversation. I don’t really process it for the first minute or so, and I continue talking. Eventually, I’m caught up to just about where I need to be, and say something along the lines of, “Wait, what now about Jefferson?”

She then spends—I’m not joking—two hours solely giving me an explanation as to why she despises Jefferson. During this, she weaves multiple Supreme Court cases with the Constitution along with outcomes in the present into a coherent narrative as to why a single action that Jefferson made can be directly tied to almost every modern Constitutional violation, on top of almost everything wrong in America.

Now, you may think, “Wait, that sounds silly; there’s no way!”

But as it turns out…yeah, that’s basically how it was? The Louisiana Purchase can be directly tied to all of those things, and Jefferson was responsible for it. It was a single bad decision that’s butterflied into most of the problems facing America today.

@kick @mewmew @lnxw37a2 @freemo @mobius

I'm guessing she was talking about the "necessary and proper" clause, which is cited in most Supreme Court rulings upholding some expansion of federal government power not laid out in the constitution.

Also, she may have been talking about Alexander Hamilton. Hamilton may have been the primary author of the Federalist Papers, but he was also one of the biggest proponents of the inclusion of that clause, and even assured people at the time it would only apply to powers given by the constitution. Perhaps unsurprisingly, he himself used this clause to justify the creation of the First Bank, a power not given to the federal government anywhere in the constitution.

@dave @mewmew @lnxw37a2 @freemo @mobius She was not speaking about Alexander Hamilton, and she wasn't speaking about that clause. If you check downthread (you aren't mentioned within because a certain lightsaber blobcat thought it would be kosher to unmention you), I elaborated more.

@kick @mewmew @lnxw37a2 @freemo @mobius

I'm really confused, then. What does that land purchase have to do with invalidating the 10th Amendment?

@dave @mewmew @lnxw37a2 @freemo @mobius The Constitution doesn't grant the right to purchase land to the federal government. The Tenth Amendment notes very explicitly that any right not guaranteed within the Constitution isn't the federal government's:

"The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."

Jefferson himself admitted that it was effectively a Constitutional violation:

"Our confederation is certainly confined to the limits established by the revolution. The general government has no powers but such as the constitution has given it; and it has not given it a power of holding foreign territory, & still less of incorporating it into the Union. An amendment of the Constitution seems necessary for this. In the meantime we must ratify & pay our money, as we have treated, for a thing beyond the constitution, and rely on the nation to sanction an act done for its great good, without its previous authority."
Follow

@kick

Except the constitution **does** grant the right of the federal government to take land for public use. It is called eminent domain, and aside from being Common Law it is granted by the 5th amendment by the phrase "nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation." implying that as long as just compensation is given the government may take the land for public use.

@mewmew @dave @lnxw37a2 @mobius

@freemo@qoto.o That’s the most egregious misinterpretation of the Fifth Amendment I’ve ever seen. Not only that, but your interpretation can be trivially disproven with what you quoted alone.

Eminent domain, as defined in the Fifth Amendment, is on forced acquisition of private property from individuals. The full text makes this clear, which you leave out (I have to assume intentionally, because your suggested interpretation but for malicious intention is something much worse than intention):

No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or in the Militia, when in actual service in time of War or public danger; nor shall any person be subject for the same offence to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb; nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.

However, the full text isn’t necessary to prove your statement wrong:

The Louisiana Purchase not only wasn’t compelled, it also wasn’t of private property.

Now, it takes some gall to disagree with the framers on the Constitution, I’ll give you that, but you’re not even doing it in a particularly clever, convincing or even reasonable way.

A more clever way to argue against Jefferson’s viewpoint is by claiming that it’s protected in the Treaty Clause, and I’d recommend you go with that next time.

There’s probably a typo or logical error in here somewhere; I’ll review after posting at some point, maybe tomorrow.

rg @mewmew @dave @lnxw37a2 @mobius

@kick

LOL its not my definition. Its been the interpretation of every supreme court since its writing, directly referenced in defense of Eminent Domain in any related court cases, and not to mention the intended interpretation by the founding fathers who wrote it (as can be seen from the comments they made during their life).

The full text was left out because the other clauses speak of unrelated issues.

@mewmew @dave @lnxw37a2 @mobius

@kick

Here is a specific quote by William Patterson, one of the signers of the constitution. He is specifically talking about eminent domain and the 5th amendment. So again, not **my** definition:

The despotic power, as it is aptly called by some writers, of taking private property, when state necessity requires, exists in every government; the existence of such power is necessary; government could not subsist without it. -- William Patterson

@mewmew @dave @lnxw37a2 @mobius

@kick @mewmew Last time I spent all night arguing with the guy because he claimed women dominate men at endurance sports. You're not gonna anywhere with this guy.

@dave @mewmew That's interesting, because it's a clear example of poor extrapolation. Women do happen to have better average performance for certain ultra-endurance sports, but the effect isn't seen with endurance sports as much, certainly nowhere near "domination."

Come to think of it, poor extrapolation sums up a majority of wrongness in the world. How sad (and profitable)!
Sign in to participate in the conversation
CleverLibre Social

CleverLibre Social is an inclusive social instance for open discussion, learning, and community.
All cultures welcome.
Hate speech and harassment strictly forbidden.