The system lets police officers request footage from users, who can agree or decline.. What exactly is the problem?
Yes, what part am i getting wrong.. as long as the user is in control of their own footage whats the problem
...the police dont have access...
There is a system that they can request footage on an individual basis, they dont have live access..
How is that even different than any other surveillance system like digital video, the police can ask you for footage when a crime is committed and you can decide to give it to them or not.
sounds a lot less scary when you call it what it actually is rather than relying on hyperbole.
What a solid counter argument.. lol I guess when you cant actually explain yourself in a coherent way and express your concerns thats about all you'd have to go to.
and yet you've already wasted far more than 10 seconds of both of our time.. funny that.
You seem to be laboring under the assumption people opt-in and then provide a live feed to the police. If that were the case then yes your issues would be relevant.
That however is **not** how this works. Police can request specific footage for a specific time period when a crime is committed, that is all. A person can approve or deny giving over that snippet of footage but they don't simply opt-in to giving away live access.
So almost all of your concerns dissolve away with that fact.. there is no sense of density in participation, or surveillance going on in the sense that you describe.
Now if you want to talk about the issue that cops in some countries (like the USA) can overreach with their power and bully you into getting footage where you might not otherwise approve, or you denying might make you a suspect, that is of course a legitimate issue. But it is hardly an issue that this particular technology has much to do with. It would be no different than if you had an old school survelance system and police showed up and you denied them. Worthy of addressing yes, but largely unrelated to this system at hand.
I am all for reducing the power of the state, but should a person have the ability to be an informant of a crime if that person wants to.. hell yea.. If I saw someone get murdered on my front door step would I like to have a system that lets me give that footage to the police, you bet. do I also want to make sure **I** have the power over that footage, ideally yes.
So whats the solution? don't allow people to share footage even if they want to? Make it illegal... Where are you even going with this?
That seems a bit absurd.. you have an issue with police departments setting up infrastructure to digitally request surveillance footage in case of crimes.. That solves nothing and only requires police to spend more time and money violating your rights and being just as effective at it in the end.
You want to solve the problem, then take my advice, focus on eliminating the overreach of pwoer and holding police accountable whent ehy do and stop trying to be reactive with nonsense like this.
**you** dont understand the problem, and it has nothing to do with the fact that a digital system for submitting footage is available, it has to do with the way in which that power can be abused, and thus solving the problem comes with eliminating the abuse of the power. Any other way will simply fail and serve to do nothing but add costs and add no additional freedoms.
Sure.. except you arent preventing anything, you have it backwards.. your just causing the police department to cost more to violate your rights as much as ever. Nothing else.
If you had an actual solution that would have a positive impact rather than just trying to waste money as a preventative measure I might agree with you.
Me, I prefer to actually solve problems rather than go about a convoluted way to reactively clean up the fallout of a problem that already exists.
Your way of thinking is exactly why the abuse of power from cops has been able to proliferate. It doesnt solve problems it just attempts to monkey patch the problem and achieves nothing.
@p @freemo @jack @judgedread @l0wk3y >Lastly, are you a cop? my sides went into orbit
obviously he’s a cop